doctorow at August 23rd, 2013 08:44 — #1
snig at August 23rd, 2013 09:13 — #2
spunkytws at August 23rd, 2013 10:08 — #3
Better than using the infamous hundred-sided die that one of my friends bought. He could have made one himself by painting numbers on a golf ball.
jim1234 at August 23rd, 2013 10:27 — #4
First edition D&D in the 8" x 5" pamphlet format was my first encounter with D&D in the mid 1970s. It was simple and left lots of room for interpretation and imagination. AD&D made it more complex without adding a lot to the experience. The key thing about D&D and paper, pencil and dice based RPGs was that they brought people together around a table for a shared experience. Computer RPGs, single or multi-player, involve less imagination, more repetition and less connection with other people. I'm sure I'm being nostalgic, but in hindsight, for me, RPGs have all been downhill since those first D&D sessions with old friends.
I've gotten rid of boxes of AD&D books and modules, but I still have my old 1st ed. D&D pamphlet set. Maybe I'll give it to my kid and see what she can make happen with it.
snig at August 23rd, 2013 10:56 — #5
I play 3.5 in a weekly online game using Klooge with friends I gamed with heavily in the 80's and early 90's. We're in four different states, but it still has the feel of sitting around the table with them. We used to be interrupted by the occasional parent, now we're interrupted by the occasional kid.
nelsie at August 23rd, 2013 11:13 — #6
A D20 would have sides to small to fit the title on.
spunkytws at August 23rd, 2013 11:14 — #7
While I agree that AD&D made it more complex I don't know that this was necessarily a bad thing. Admittedly I have almost no experience with early D&D. My friends and I, who started playing a few years later than you did, skipped right over D&D and went right for the advanced version. We saw it as a worthwhile tradeoff: there were more rules, but also more options.
And if there was one rule that our group adhered to it was that the rules should never get in the way of having a good time. For us they weren't rules so much as suggestions.
jim1234 at August 23rd, 2013 11:59 — #8
seanc0x0 at August 23rd, 2013 12:10 — #9
I desperately wanted one of those when I was 10. When a friend got one, we rolled it a few times, then went back to the 2D10 system. It was just too impractical.
codinghorror at August 23rd, 2013 13:00 — #10
jandrese at August 23rd, 2013 13:13 — #11
I heard this guy on NPR a few days ago. He came across as a non-gamer trying to write about some strange subculture he had just discovered by "going native" just long enough to get his story.
The subtitle on the book should be a concern to anybody who knows D&D. Level 12 is not especially high, and he has only apparently ever played a single character, probably in a single group with a same DM. He's trying to write about an entire culture of people from the very narrow slice he personally visited. Maybe if we're really lucky he managed to make a trip to Gencon while writing the book, and we'll get the chapter where he wanders around lost in bewildered amazement at all of the weirdness everywhere.
spunkytws at August 23rd, 2013 13:46 — #12
I was befuddled by the fact that the hundred sided die only made it to #7 until I saw the others. I had seen, but forgotten, crystal dice and gold dice, but...the D34? And I'm not sure I want to live in a world where there's actually something worse than the D34.
noahdjango at August 23rd, 2013 15:05 — #13
I lost my composure a few times, but the best was no doubt last, the bit about using the mona lisa for kindling in particular
boundegar at August 23rd, 2013 18:15 — #14
If you were really one of us, you wouldn't even need to ask. But at least you didn't say dodecahedron.
snig at August 23rd, 2013 18:43 — #15
Not asking, disparaging:
It's a bit like putting a viola on a book about orchestral instruments.
jhbadger at August 23rd, 2013 19:22 — #16
An earlier, similar work (but covering more than D&D but the entire RPG/wargaming hobby) is Jon Peterson's Playing at the World. It;s quite a long read, but interesting if you like the subject.
doctorow at August 23rd, 2013 22:17 — #17
You're entirely, totally wrong. As my writeup, the publishers' summary, and many reviews around the web make clear, he played many, many characters, in many games, for decades. He went to many gaming cons. He sat in on a session DM'ed by Ernie Gygax, who played the first-ever D&D game, with his dad Gary. He LARPed.
Honestly, I could see being concerned that this might be the case, but I can't see publicly opining that it "probably" is, when a moment's -- a half-moment's! -- research would have shown otherwise. It's pretty poor, really.
mister44 at August 23rd, 2013 23:28 — #18
Does the books have any useful tips, like how to get Cheetos stains out of shirts?
boundegar at August 23rd, 2013 23:34 — #19
Yes but it involves a fireball spell.
codinghorror at August 24th, 2013 01:00 — #20
next page →