I have always felt that Godwinning is a form of blackface against those actually affected by the atrocities of that regime. So revulsion is properly felt in both cases when the user is a white american trying to either aggressively invoke their own group historical application or to appropriate the historical suffering of a minority group. OTOH I have seen Godwin invoked specifically by white americans to prevent those affected by that genocide and many previous from drawing parallels to something which has been a problem to most generations for thousands of years.
It is similar to the blackface like disgust against Jews for Jesus. The above abortion bomber grade and a few steps above Christian wants to convert all Jews to Christianity to bring the end of days and the real rule of god-king Jesus. They dress up as Jews(*badly to comic effect) attend normal synagogues and appropriate only when convenient the narrative, culture, and religion; all to eliminate the troubling concept of Jews from the world except as expressed by Christianity.
*there is nothing like going to a reform temple bat-mitzvah and seeing some j4j dork trying to spread the ‘good news’ dressed up like a cheap costume shop hasidic Jew when a real hasid is nearly as out of place browsing the shrimp cocktail bar as an Amish guy in a fighter jet. The sadly comic value only increases when he loudly argues with the cops called to escort him out, maybe not for the embarrassed 12 year old girl though.
Not even funny or atypical version of this blackfacing when the possibility arises was the J4J pastor(fake rabbi) who appropriated the passover kits during the Iraq war donated into the military chaplain supply chain by Jewish congregations and diverted them to reinterpreted fake-passover take-my-body-and-blood for fun communion/passover experience meals for Christian soldiers and duped Jews. I seem to recall there being an emergency delivery and distribution through the US Navy supply chain directed through an amphibious assault ship to get around the broken Army chaplain supply chain.
