He’s pointing out a great big hole in your credibility. I read the Gizmodo piece. It takes into account the lack of credit card info very well. The writer was a woman, after all - she couldn’t very well set up a paid account when she was researching the story. She analysed the dumped data - you know, the stuff that real users would be aghast at seeing get out? The kind of stuff that has already sparked class actions?
Welcome to Boing Boing. I think you may soon have the interesting experience of meeting a dragon.