Bill Nye won the evolution/creation debate ... but not for the reason you think

That’s what they heard because that’s what they were expecting to hear. They weren’t actually thinking about what Nye was saying, they were trying to filter his words through their worldview. To them this was a science vs. religion debate, so that’s what they heard. This is also at the heart of the amazingly high percentage of Americans that believe in creationism, they have been sold the idea that accepting evolution requires the rejection of God.