It seems that the major disagreement here is no over Internet access but over the definition of “right”. Some say a right is something violence may be justly used to defend/obtain. Others that a right is anything necessary to sustain life. Going even further still others define it as whatever is necessary for a satisfactory life.
Along with this is the question of from whence rights come. Some say rights are obtained from a person’s very existence or from God. Others say by the common consent of society. Yet others say the government is the creator of rights.