I don’t think you have enough information to make that determination, and I do think that to jump to this conclusion instead of, say, asking for clarification constitutes bad faith argumentation.
Maybe you should ask yourself something like the following: “Am I trying to understand what the other person is saying? Or am I trying to score points or shut their perspective out of the discussion?”
Also, you haven’t given your own definition of “fair” or made it clear what you would require for someone else’s usage to pass muster under your obviously stringent requirements.
I don’t think this discussion is going anywhere fruitful, though. It doesn’t seem like you have any intention of considering anyone else’s perspective on the subject. Have a good day.
