The original Whitson-Galinsky study (and Ed Yong’s report on it) was from 2008, too early for PubPeer or RetractionWatch. But it is featured in a 2014 review of “Excess Success for Psychology Articles in the Journal Science”, as part of a general indictment of junk science:
null findings have been suppressed, that the experiments or analyses were inappropriate, or that the theory does not properly follow from the data […] a systematic pattern of excess success among psychology articles in the journal Science.
