I think it’s inevitable that, when gathering up many samples of a given trope, you’re necessarily going to include some things that are subjective enough that reasonable people may differ.
To give a less fraught example, you can look at any random page on TvTropes and you’ll find things cited as trope examples that seem iffy at best
If Tropes vs Women were confined only to entirely unambiguous and horrible examples, that would both make it seem as though the trope were less prevalent than it is, and it would also move the line - it would say that only the completely worst examples are deserving of scrutiny and all others are hunky dory. I’m fine with games that are sort of edge-cases also getting some examination.
