And @Doctor_Faustus
Yes, it really is a strange, Heller-esque situation. Warmongers, philanderers, and thieves are winning over a group of what has traditionally been a pretty harmless subgroup of religious fundamentalists. But I think the unifying factors are the misogyny, racism, homophobia, transphobia, profit-motive, situational libertarianism, and similar strains of traditional conservative thought that has won a lot of the younger Amish folks in my area. They gloss over the evils we see because they’re afraid of being overrun by godless dems who might raise property costs and set limits on things like milk, wetland usage, etc.