It doesn’t matter if you believe me or not. I’m telling you with 100% certainty and authority on the subject…leaving your humidor open for anything more than absolutely necessary is absolutely stupid. Regardless.
Those cigars in tubes. They need to be in a humidor. The tubes are for show and relative protection for a single stick. But they do not provide moisture for the cigars to remain smokable. If they are just in the tubes and have sat for ~6months they can be salvaged. Anything past a year and forget it. They are trash at that point.