doctorow — 2013-11-03T14:50:54-05:00 — #1
danegeld — 2013-11-03T17:15:40-05:00 — #2
What this tells us is that the terrorists urgently need to go on a recruitment drive, to boost the number of genuine terrorists until their number as a percentage of the general population matches the accuracy of the terrorist identification test,. e.g. if 1% of the citizens become terrorists, then the positives have a 50% likelihood of being true. The government should also harass innocent citizens until they join the terrorist organisation, thus improving the accuracy of their test. I think this is the strategy the TSA already follows...
tuseroni — 2013-11-03T17:40:44-05:00 — #3
it's been working wonders in the middle east.
jsroberts — 2013-11-03T18:02:15-05:00 — #4
Just run the test two more times with the suspects and you have your terrorist, with a very slight margin of error. As a bonus, the second and third tests would be a hundred times more practical than the first one. /s
sr105 — 2013-11-03T18:28:33-05:00 — #5
Well done, young men. Well done.
sr105 — 2013-11-03T18:29:45-05:00 — #6
This assumes that the test has some amount of chance associated. If not, the second test will return 10,001 terrorists and 0 non-terrorists.
jsroberts — 2013-11-03T19:18:53-05:00 — #7
We're allowing that the police are capable of rounding up all of the inhabitants of L.A. and giving them a test that is exactly 99% accurate, so I'm going to assume that it's either random or they have the resources to make two similar tests with the same level of accuracy. After all, in this mental puzzle the terrorist has no associates - you're either 100% guilty or 100% innocent.
You're right though (of course): the important factor would be that any one person that they did flag up as a suspect would statistically have very little chance of being the terrorist.
pjcamp — 2013-11-03T19:41:59-05:00 — #8
Maybe when they finish that the can do something about the bananas.
indubitably — 2013-11-03T21:46:23-05:00 — #9
Mind weighs the universe.
Want to depower? Demind.
Entropy is not evil, mind is...
immutable_mike — 2013-11-04T00:30:33-05:00 — #10
No thanks. I'd like maintain a sense of mystery about bananas.
I mean, I'll look at them, but I'll just look at them.
tubacat — 2013-11-05T03:05:38-05:00 — #11
I teach math, and this is an excellent explanation of a subtle concept - great job!
doctorow — 2013-11-10T19:48:27-05:00 — #12
This topic was automatically closed after 7 days. New replies are no longer allowed.