Why does Hollywood like dystopian LAs and utopian SFs?

Then there’s the Star Trek into Darkness curveball. The utopian future in the film may have been set in San Francisco, but it was shot in Los Angeles, e.g. Starfleet Academy was shot at the Getty Center.

4 Likes

As a bay area native transplanted to Southern CA, I’ll have to agree with this, of course.
The big city north of me (I live in San Diego) has some pretty cool things in it, and I very much dig the winding streets that spill south from Mulholland Drive down to Sunset, but overall… not my favorite place.
Don’t get me started on OC.

Beautiful place. Love the architecture. Hate the art, though.

Howsabout “Her”? Quite Utopian, and definitely LA. Light Rail along the ridges, useful subway, pedestrian malls, and no cars.

That would be the 1949 novel Earth Abides by George R. Stewart. Ernest Callenbach wrote Ecotopia in '75.

2 Likes

Because LA is already full of people in a zombified state looking to cannibalize from the brains of their fellow human?

Or so I am told.

2 Likes

Hollywood also really, really loves fucking up the Golden Gate Bridge. It’s a damn monster magnet. At least the Star Trek franchise lets it off with a near miss now and then (Nero’s tunneling beam and the Bird of Prey from Star Trek IV both missed it by feet).

4 Likes

I believe the author of Earth abides is George R. Stewart.

One word: trees.

4 Likes

Not sure I follow. I’ve lived in both cities, and the presence or absence of trees in both varies dramatically by neighborhood.

1 Like

A better question is, why is California always the future? I understand that in film this is in big part due to Hollywood’s location, but this issue extends across media in general. It’s a really narrow conception of the future.

1 Like

Southern California IS a hellscape. LA. Needles. Barstow. The only difference between it now and the Mad Max future is the number of spikes on the cars.

1 Like

Because movies are made by a bunch of jackoff narcissistic egomaniacs who burn and crumble to dust if they come into contact with reality.

1 Like

I don’t mean just movies though. California is a common setting in written science fiction as well.

1 Like

Am I the only one who loves San Francisco but still gets annoyed by people who feel obligated to constantly reiterate how much they hate Los Angeles?

5 Likes

Gosh – A blog with a San Francisco-focused readership is spending the day bashing on LA.

How wonderfully… provincial.

2 Likes

I’d rather know why Hollywood only sets romantic comedies in Seattle.

4 Likes

Congress?

1 Like

oh – please do.

I live in OC. It’s changed quite a bit in the last 20 years - especially culinarily.

Which OC is it that inspires your dread?

Which one are you married to?