Amazon and Hachette kiss and make up

[Permalink]

And now weā€™re ALL screwed. . .

1 Like

Probably outdated stereotypes want to know: Did they bury the hachette?

4 Likes

Point of order: Amazon never ā€œrefused to sellā€ any of Hachetteā€™s books. They just stopped discounting them and stopped carrying an inventory of them in stock so they couldnā€™t fill customersā€™ orders until Hachette filled their own order. But Amazon was perfectly happy to let customers order themā€”unlike when the major publishers illegally imposed agency pricing and it removed Macmillanā€™s ā€œBuyā€ buttons in protest.

Nearly a year of Amazon ā€œmaking it harder to buy booksā€ from Hachette would be more accurate.

2 Likes

If Amazon refuses to sell DRM free ebooks could Hachette legally offer customers a DRM free copy with proof-of-purchase?

If Hachette wanted to sell ebooks without DRM they could just open up their own store (ala TOR) relatively easily. With eBooks there is really no need for a middleman like Amazon or any other bookstore.

You only need a middleman if you wan to add DRM and lock them to specific devices. Consumers arenā€™t going to buy a different E-Reader for every publisherā€“believe me, the publishers tried. Thatā€™s why you see crazy dance with Amazon, whom the publishers hate with every fiber of their being but are also trapped with since they canā€™t imagine a world where digital goods are sold without arbitrary customer punishing restrictions.

2 Likes

Amazon donā€™t refuse to sell DRM-free ebooks.

I am concerned about Amazonā€™s Walmart like power, but books donā€™t ā€˜lock you into their walled garden foreverā€™.

Itā€™s the use case.

Most people donā€™t re-read books at all.

Nobody reads books on shuffle.

Books take a long time to read, so an app switch is trivial.

Amazon e books are available on all significant platforms.

Music has the power to lock people in because people listen to lots of songs in quick sequence. And re-listen a lot.

Apps have the power because they are often locked to an os and therefore to some hardware and because you put your data into them.

Books just donā€™t.

Talk to the people whose copies of Nineteen Eighty-Four were vanished along with their own notes. Itā€™s also insanely short-sighted to be okay with not being able to export the stuff you paid for to another device. Iā€™m sure the creators of the 8 inch floppy thought youā€™d always be able to read them easily as well.

Music locks people in? Only through laziness or subscription. itunes downloads are DRM free.

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.