Bad for You: Exposing the War on Fun!




I wish to buy this for my kid, but I suppose his mother would burn it.


That timeline of the war on fun represents very poor logic. You can't argue that someone is wrong about the potential dangers of technology just because someone else was wrong about an earlier technology. This kind of logic would have it that smoking cannot possibly be harmful to health, because in the past people were wrong about health effects of other habits, such as chewing gum, winter hiking, etc).

Carr's arguments about neuroplasticity might lack rigorous scientific backing, but there is plenty of evidence that the pervasive distractions of modern tech can be harmful, and that kids need more help these days to develop the skills to manage distractibility. Similarly, while there's no evidence that being online is any more likely to expose kids to sexual predators than hanging out in the streets, that doesn't mean that the de-individuating effects of online interaction aren't real.

The techno-optimists are wrong about the benefits of technology just as often as the techno-pessimists are. Meanwhile the rest of us have to figure out how to navigate a world in which every new technology brings both benefits and problems, often in equal measure.


What is that skateboarding monster’s head supposed to be? A… haunted Torah… wearing binoculars? I can’t understand what I’m looking at.


Seriously? It's a Playstation controller.


I took an extra kid with us to go sledding yesterday, and for about 30 seconds I did seriously consider whether or not I should ask the parents if they wanted their kid to wear a helmet. Not because I thought it was in any way necessary, but because I've seen too much hypervigilance among parents over the years to take common sense for granted anymore.


OH! Now I see it. My brain was interpreting the handles as cylinders in perspective and the buttons as negative space, like film reels. So it looked like some kind of scroll.


Thanks for the post! Now I am out the cost of the book as it looks too good to pass up. Ordered and will be here soon. Yay for good comics writing!


I can still hear teachers from my past using the "disrupting the class" ploy whenever they needed to win an argument.


This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.