Guard tells top senator that she can't take notes on TPP

[Permalink]

2 Likes

Wait, they did?

They did!

Thank you, Mitch McConnell!

1 Like

It’s rare that I’m moved to issue McConnell an attaboy, but here we are.

4 Likes

The secrecy is to keep the public from knowing what’s in it, otherwise most people would be opposed.
The lawmakers are kept from knowing the details as well, certainly not for trade reasons because the governments already negotiating already know what is involved, and some lawmakers would probably be opposed as well. Let’s face it, the players involved are large multi-national corporations that are outside one country’s jurisdiction and the “freer” trade is not about getting rid of tariffs as there are very few of those but ‘de-regulation’ which sounds great like getting rid of red-tape but really is about getting rid of environmental laws, safety regulations, labour code, etc. WHICh is why most people would be opposed if they found out that for instance some corporation that puts chemical additives into say gasoline would be able to sue a government that disallows that for environmental reasons.
The secrecy is not just before and during the negotiations but is intended to continue for years until the trade agreement is an established fact and very difficult to get out of.

4 Likes

It’s just a little bit surprising that the whole thing hasn’t been leaked to the public by now. There are enough sufficiently motivated individuals out there with the know-how, surely?

5 Likes

Call it fascism, call it corporatism, I call it treason. When the law of the land is kept secret from its citizens, how is that not tyranny?

20 Likes

We’re way beyond that—the law is now kept secret from the people whose sole responsibility is to write, debate and vote on laws.

22 Likes

Think of it this way, if there is a god, and I’m not saying there is,
but. . .
if there is a god,
These guys are all going to burn in HELL.

1 Like

Wait, are you thanking McConnell for blocking the bill? You know he’s in favor of it, right?

3 Likes

Hrm, guess I misunderstood. He gets an attaboy if he’s helping kill it.

Otherwise it’s the same old shit from that guy.

EDIT: Crap, further reading here at Ars seems to back you up. Same old dickery. Thanks for catching me on that.

7 Likes

Here’s how secrecy in a trade treaty is theoretically justified.

Borduria protects its agriculture interest with high tariffs.
Syldavia protects its timber interests with high tariffs.

Borduria and Syldavia negotiate an agreement that essentially opens up agriculture and timber markets in both countries. They sign an agreement, which Borduria promptly ratifies.

Syldavian timber interests then pressure the Syldavian legislature to add a codicil to block imports of Bordurian timber, while insisting that Borduria abide by the treaty as negotiated… Naturally, Borduria declines, and withdraws from the treaty.

A waste of time, says Colonel Müstler, as he makes plans to ensure that this won’t happen again.

TPP is a multilateral treaty, which complicates all the negotiations.

But closed door negotiations ignore the real dangers of trusting trade negotiators.

2 Likes

this whole TPP thing is just shitty.

3 Likes

Robert Reich has a good 2.5-minute rundown here: https://youtu.be/3O_Sbbeqfdw

Dear TPP pimps: “If you’ve got nothing to hide, you’ve got nothing to fear”

6 Likes

I have no actual comment, I just loved your comparisons. The Order of the Golden Pelican for you!

5 Likes

That’s so very comforting, Mr. armchair theologian.

I’m sure these people burning in hell 40 odd years or so from now will definitely have an enormously positive effect on all of the not dead people who have to live with the consequences of these fucker’s treason.
/Sarc

I’d say we’d be better off burning them here on earth just to be sure, than simply imagining they’ll go to some abstract bad place in the future, as long as they don’t get right with “god”.

If there is a god, it’s pretty obvious he doesn’t give a flying fuck what happens on earth, so we better take matters into our own hands. Because sky daddy has been drunk for the last…Forever… and never seems to be interested in our macaroni art, or watching us jump off the diving board.

5 Likes

If there was a god, she wouldn’t let these mortals crown themselves demigods and run roughshod over her creation

2 Likes

Also, if you’re thinking of the Abrahamic god, this entire mess is his fault anyway. In fact all bad things are directly his fault because he knew they were going to happen (omnicient) and could have stopped them (omnipotent) without even having to worry about physical or logical impossibility (resides outside of the universe and isn’t constrained to the universe’s rules about reality.)

Therefor all bad things that happen are the will of such a god, and that god is in fact evil, and not worth even worshiping if it existed anyway.

3 Likes

So much fud. The text of the entire bill will be made public before it is ratified, even if fast track authority is granted. There will be a final vote with full disclosure of the bill’s contents before it is made law of land.

This just makes the initial negation possible without much meddling by congress until the end.

Hi, welcome!

I hope you enjoy your stay here at BBS, however long you choose to make it, and will continue to make insightful comments about a multitude of topics.

6 Likes