Planetary overprotection: Have we made ourselves Mars' helicopter parents?

[Permalink]

ā€œhospitable to tagalong life from Earthā€ is relative right? From what I know of Mars, nothing from Earth will survive there as anything other than a dormant spore, no matter where you are on the planet.

I certainly wouldnā€™t be booking tickets with plucky optimism about living on the land; but Iā€™d probably bet a few hundred bucks on some earthly extremophiles being just ducky either under such polar ice as their is(dormant much; but not all, of the time), and possibly subsurface in some of the lower-elevation parts of the planet, where there is still something vaguely resembling an atmosphere.

Perhaps more importantly: If earthly life, of any flavor, can survive (in a metabolically active way) on Mars, odds are good (Iā€™d put considerably more money on this one) that the overlap between ā€˜places earth life can liveā€™ and ā€˜places remnants of mars life are holding outā€™ is significant.

Thatā€™s the real downer. It doesnā€™t matter if 99% of the planet is too brutal to do anything but kill spores slowly, if the 1% that might contain something of vast scientific interest is the same 1% that earthly life would be happy to have a go atā€¦

The lack of liquid water is a real buzzkill for Earth based life. The Atacama Desert on Earth has similar conditions in places, and is notably devoid of even bacterial life in the soil.

Thatā€™s why Iā€™m perfectly unconcerned about writing off 95+% of the planetary surface as biologically viable. Too dry, too cold, atmosphere so thin that the vapor pressure of just about anything biological is remarkably high by comparison. Itā€™s just that if there are any exceptions, those exceptions are probably where the martian life would be making its last stand as well (unless itā€™s something radically different from life as we know it). Thatā€™s the contamination that Iā€™d be concerned about avoiding.

1 Like

Martian. When did academic English stop distinguishing adjectives from nouns? Why?

1 Like

uGH, let aplanet be, woodyah?

:wink:

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.