Systems of education and its discontents

11 Likes

Gotta pay the sportsball coaches somehow, right?

11 Likes

schitts creek hello GIF by CBC

I was gonna say that we don’t even have that excuse, but then I remembered that GSU bought out the community college I teach part time at, and so, yeah… :rage:

8 Likes

:face_with_symbols_over_mouth:

12 Likes
8 Likes

I mean, I guess… but seems to me that the “we” way of thinking about academia has long covered over a whole host of exploitative practices by those professors with power over undergrads, grad students, younger professors, etc. Since it was “self-governing” there were few guardrails on that kind of thing, and plenty of people took advantage when they could. :woman_shrugging:

6 Likes

He does address that.

The reality was inevitably less egalitarian and communitarian than this picture suggests, in all sorts of ways. Senior professors had too much power and inevitably, some of them abused it. And, given the times, lots of bad behaviour was tolerated that would not be now.

For good and ill, this has all been swept away, at least in Australia. Multiple layers of management are filled by people who have either left the academic life behind them or were never part of it. The university in this view, is not a community but a business enterprise, even if its ownership structure is rather opaque.

And it’s not like the bad parts have entirely gone away (although I have seen some egregious examples dealt with), but he’s asking whether the idea of collegiality had to go out with the bad.

4 Likes

Yeah, I saw… still. I think he’s downplaying the very real problems that existed in academia. What’s coming to replace it isn’t better by any stretch, but…

Also true.

I think perhaps we can start looking at the current crisis as at least a chance to be rid of the old exploitative system and try to rethink what academia could be. If there are high ideals there, maybe we try and live up to those.

I don’t know…

5 Likes

5 Likes

Use AI to convert course readings into podcasts? Why not!

(Well, for one thing, would students even bother to read them, then?)

I suggest listening for a bit at the bottom of this page to the podcast that another new Google tool made of a chapter on Deconstruction. It’s pretty hard to distinguish from two actual people talking about Deconstruction.

https://cwi.pressbooks.pub/lit-crit/part/gap-structuralism-and-deconstruction/

4 Likes

7 Likes

“The Publisher Defendants’ Scheme has three primary components,” the complaint states. First, the publishers have “agreed” (a claim that is key to an antitrust suit) not to compensate scholars providing peer review services. Second, the publishers have agreed to require that scholars submit their manuscripts to only one journal at a time. And third, that the publishers have agreed to prohibit scholars from “freely sharing the scientific advancements described in submitted manuscripts” while those manuscripts are under peer review, a process that can take months.

In the “publish or perish world of academia," the publishers have "essentially agreed to hold the careers of scholars hostage” the complaint, filed by named plaintiff Lucina Uddin, a UCLA neuroscientist, on behalf of a potential class of academic authors, states. The filing goes on to call the peer review process “a scheme” agreed to by publishers to bolster their profits.

“Through the Scheme, the Publisher Defendants have sustained profit margins that far exceed the most successful corporations in the economy. For instance, in 2023, Elsevier alone generated $3.8 billion in revenue from its peer-reviewed journals, with an operating profit margin of 38%,” the complaint states. “In 2023, the Publishing Defendants together received over $10 billion in revenue from their peer-reviewed journals. These astounding revenues and profits margins are sustained through collusion, and unlawfully divert billions of taxpayer dollars every year from science to the Publisher Defendants.”

7 Likes

ETNA - Electronic Transactions in Numerical Analysis was established in 1992 to address these very problems. The website is looking spiffier these days.

It can be done.

3 Likes

10 Likes

Where are Methods, Results and Discussion? What did they do to Methods, Results and Discussion!?!

6 Likes

scoffs in postmodernism

focus GIF

7 Likes

I thought this was interesting. I have no frame of reference for this, though. I’m one of those small number of people mentioned in the video that basically taught themselves how to read. I learned to read when I was 4, according to my parents. I literally have no memory of a time when I couldn’t read, so I have no idea how I learned it. My parents read a lot to me, and I guess I followed along and figured it out. I suspect Sesame Street and the Electric Company helped out.

7 Likes

I love her videos…

4 Likes
8 Likes

https://www.politico.com/news/2024/09/30/california-bans-legacy-admissions-colleges-00181655

4 Likes