The Earth and I – is climate change moving too fast for a new book on climate change?


#1

Originally published at: http://boingboing.net/2016/11/28/the-earth-and-i-is-climate.html


#2

So the premise is that books on climate change are too dated by the time they are published to be effective...

...and this person made their case...

...in a book.


#3

I think the person making that case is Ben Marks, and he's making the case in a blog post on BoingBoing by discussing this particular book.


#4

Geez they added HFC's to the Montreal Protocol on October 15th 2016. Like barely more than a month ago.

If Ben knew anything about publishing he'd know that this book was likely penned at least a year ago.

It's ironic, but it's hardly worth the scolding.

If I was going to piss and moan about every dumb thing said about biology in books I'd be dehydrated and hoarse.


#5

So it is. I got the impression that the book, The Earth and I, was about dated publications rather than this being a review of The Earth and I.

I hadn't seen an honestly critical assessment, instead of a thinly disguised ad, of a product on this site for so long that I got confused.


#6

Critical assessment ends with example of glaring outdated information.

Amazon link provided anyway.


#7

I didn't read it as a scolding, but almost a lament that things are moving so fast that books are literally out of date by the time they reach book shelves (well, a day after)


#8

The fact that HFCs are extraordinarily potent greenhouse gases has been known for a very long time so Lovelock's suggestion that they're "less harmful to the planetary environment" was only correct if you take a very narrow interpretation of what is harmful to the environment.

I'd be more interested to hear what he's got to say more generally about climate change in this book because a lot of what he's been saying recently is, quite frankly, pretty extreme and counterproductive.


#9

don't you mean... disappointed?


#10

I was reading about the difficulty of finding a substitute for CFCs and HFCs in heat pumps — trying to find something that wasn't itself a global warming gas.

Is there something intrinsic about the physical property of good heat pump gasses that also happens to make them particularly good at trapping the Earth's heat?


#11

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.