The 'mystery' of who built the earthen mounds in the Midwest was nothing but white dude propaganda

I am ordering this right about now. Thank you for recommending this to me.

I discovered Macauley in my school library when I was in third grade, and have loved him ever since. Both my kids have his books on their shelves. But somehow this one escaped me.

1 Like

Is this still considered a mystery? I grew up in the shadow of the Great Serpent Mound in Ohio, and even in my little rural school, they taught us that it was made by the Fort Ancient culture.

1 Like

Next you’re going to tell me those Mystery Spot locations aren’t actually anything special.

4 Likes

One popular theory these days is that they were for teaching about birth.

I saw water flow uphill and a chair balance on two legs, with my own eyes!! (and, this being the late '70s, it was attributed to “Indian Magic”. See how I tied it back to the OP? :slight_smile:

5 Likes

All I said was that sometimes I don’t feel like a nut! I didn’t realize it would cause so much controversy…

7 Likes

this sort of propaganda is still alive

4 Likes

For the African version, see here:

Long, but very good.

2 Likes

Before this thread gets closed again: Is this another case of US exceptionalism? Because grand Native American architecture is not questioned south of the Rio Grande.

3 Likes

Yeah,some of the afrocentrists claim the moundbuilders.

Lots of crackpots all around.

that’s from “They came before Columbus”-- in the bibliography for Akala’s talk

Kinda shaped like pyramids of sorts.

white people also claim the headwaters of Donny Brook, near yon marble head.

so is the eiffel tower; steel having a steeper angle of repose than your average stony loam.

1 Like

@milliefink already gave you all the answer you deserve, but just to satisfy any lingering debate…

Because it’s a false equivalency clearly meant to be provocative and elicit an emotional reaction as opposed to a reasoned point of discussion. To wit: The population of North America at the time period this article refers to was racially mixed with approximately 83.8% European heritage 15.6% African, and approximately 1.4% Native N American (though that last number is very fudgy due to a number of factors, mainly racism), while Uganda in the time period you are referencing (now) the racial breakdown is 91% African of various tribal ancestry, 1% European descent and 8% “Other”. The clearly disingenuous falsehood in your logic is that, while the motivations of crime in Uganda may be ethnically motivated, they are not committed en masse by races alien to the region as they were by European-heritage white people against indigenous North American populations. Therefore, it is cogent to the topic to refer to these people as white, yet would be completely irrelevant to a discussion about Ugandan violence. Ya dig?

2 Likes

I was thinking more of the white historians’ habit of claiming that African civilisations were not created by Africans.

4 Likes

Most of that talk is based in mainstream history; in a few places, he mentions some less well-accepted theories (regarding Africa, not the Americas), but explicitly flags that he’s doing so as he does.

There is no claim made in that talk regarding American mound-builders.

5 Likes

But don’t you see how important it is to always point out that both sides do it?

/s

4 Likes

It may not be questioned by many people south of the Rio Grande, but it is still subject to the same woo as we find north of the border.

Some claim direct links between ancient Egypt and ancient Mesoamerica. Because different civilizations couldn’t possibly come up with pyramids independently, right? It’s all part of the “advanced antediluvian global civilization that They don’t want you to know about” conspiracy, or the ancient aliens conspiracy, and I’m sure someone has figured out how to merge the two grand conspiracies.

Some of this stuff has a pretty good veneer of plausibility, because why wouldn’t it if the people who peddle it (and in some cases actually believe it) spend a lifetime honing their arguments? And some of it lacks even a little veneer.

1 Like