What makes a movie a Western?

I see your Aussie and raise you one Japan:

and one Korean

The former is just ok to me. The latter is a masterpiece of homage to the spaghetti western.

9 Likes

For instance:

3 Likes

The Wild Bunch is set in the earliest 20th C. and considered a classic that revived the genre.

5 Likes

John Wayne even tried tihe same as a response to that with Big Jake.

2 Likes

Yes, because there is no way that these regions might have overlap… /s

Once again… OK is VERY MUCH on this map of the SW…

But yes, OK IS part of the Southwest and it could also be considered part of the south…

9 Likes

Texas was part of the confederacy. It’s not part of the Southwest. And westerns can’t be set there. /s

6 Likes

You know what was a great Western? Hawaii Five-O. America can’t get much further west than that.

10 Likes


4 Likes

I’ve seen a few movies and shows set in Hawaii already. We need to have more movies set in American Samoa, or maybe Guam.

6 Likes

If it doesn’t have ham, green bell peppers and onions- it’s not a western.

13 Likes

And if it does and is in the west, it’s a Denver.

12 Likes

If a Denver has cheese- it’s a midwestern.

6 Likes

The most Western Western there is. It even has Henry Fonda in it.

6 Likes

John Wayne is in it?

3 Likes

How about the Austrian Alps? The 19th century happened on a lot of places and as long as they have a frontier aspect they qualify as the setting of a Western.

7 Likes

I was pretty bummed right off the bat watching Next Goal Wins and realizing it was very clearly filmed in Hawaii.

3 Likes

Films set in the 20th Cthat are westerns

Films set in Oklahoma that are westerns (for example)

5 Likes

If you enjoyed the movie, I highly recommend the book as well. It’s not just a great western; it’s also a masterful adaptation.

4 Likes

…and one Thai?

7 Likes

“If it’s not filmed in Spain and directed by an Italian, it’s not a Western”.

  • My Dad.
    (fan of spaghetti)
16 Likes