I think that the role of an educator is to encourage critical thinking and debate, and that this is a totally inappropriate way to address “controversial” material in schools.
It’s weird. When I hear about books being censored, it always makes me scratch my head that it almost always happens in schools that are more privileged than the one I went to. OK, so I’m looking at their website and they look like a pretty typical high school, but bear with me a moment.
My old high school is in a town that has less than 800 people. My graduating class had less than 40 people in it. (I love the stats on Wikipedia; according to their stats, they’re 1.15% Hispanic; that’s 0.9 people. I know they have at least one, LOL) But back then (late 80s to early 90s) I could go into the small library and find every single book that was most frequently banned. I could find Stephen King (don’t judge, please), along with a small selection of Heinlein, Asimov, Clarke, and so on. In my senior year, we read Catcher In The Rye. And that teacher didn’t shy away from anything.
To put this even more in perspective, I used to spend my summers mostly at my grandma’s house, where I would literally have to go to an outhouse to go to the toilet. One of the things I’d keep myself occupied with on a rainy day, when Grandma wasn’t giving me something to do, was play solitaire. When one particular uncle visited, the cards had to be put away, because they’re a tool of the Devil. And according to Mom, that’s how it had been when she was a kid; you just didn’t have playing cards.
And another thing about this little town is that they’re pretty poor, and very white. Rumor has it, though, that they fought to keep public housing out because it’d mean they’d have to let Those People move in! So reading The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, along with watching reruns of Star Trek (no joke), was a real eye-opener. Wait, so Jim is one of the few decent human beings in the story, about the only one with any honor, and the white people looking down on him act like animals? Yes. Wait, so Sulu doesn’t talk like he just got off the boat? There’s Asian people who aren’t first-generation? Yes. (Californians, don’t laugh, please.)
So on the former, I get a little bent out of shape when Huckleberry Finn gets banned, and I get told to shut up my privileged mouth and listen. No…you listen. That book made me (imho) a better person. If I hadn’t read it, I’d probably have just believed all those friends and family who said that black people were inferior. I probably never would have started reading other writings from that time, or comparing and contrasting ideas from that time and now. Having a famous author, in a book published 130 years ago, talking about issues that some people still don’t seem to get, man, that’s a punch to the gut. It’s a punch to the gut, too, to be told, “This needs to be banned, it hurts my people.” To me, they might as well be saying, “I haven’t read this, but this word is offensive.”
But, hell, I know people who would read Little Brother and agree with the school administration. They tend to be of the “whatever it takes to fight the terrorists” persuasion, and tend to have military backgrounds.