doctorow at October 6th, 2013 12:05 — #1
rocketpj at October 6th, 2013 12:17 — #2
Is killing sealife a thing we want? Do they only kill jellies, or do they kill everything in their path?
And don't jellies breed by the billions, with survival based on conditions such as available food? In other words, will this make even a micron of difference, if eliminating jellies is the actual goal?
ralph_moonen at October 6th, 2013 12:55 — #3
chrisvonholle at October 6th, 2013 12:58 — #4
Why is this a thing? When the fuck did killing jelly fish become a 'thing'?
sear at October 6th, 2013 13:09 — #5
also, doesn't shredding invertebrates like jellyfish simply produce lots more jellies from the pieces?
eark_the_bunny at October 6th, 2013 13:10 — #6
Jelly fish have caused problems with at least one nuclear power plant by clogging the intake pipes which bring in sea water to cool the plant.
jjoebus at October 6th, 2013 13:13 — #7
The first link confused me. Jeros.com seems to be the website of a company that makes kitchen machines, not jellyfish killing robots.
jim_kirk at October 6th, 2013 13:18 — #8
Obligatory "But will it Blend?" reference...
murrayhenson at October 6th, 2013 13:34 — #9
If a reasonable reaction to screwing stuff up was indiscriminate murder of a species, the entire non-human living population of the earth would be justified in rising up and killing every last human.
To put it another way: if the inhabitants of a place are going to potentially interfere with a nuclear power plant, perhaps the designers should take that into consideration and work around it rather than simply - ahem - nuking the inhabitants.
themudshark at October 6th, 2013 14:33 — #10
daemonworks at October 6th, 2013 15:51 — #12
doctorow at October 6th, 2013 15:57 — #13
timquinn at October 6th, 2013 15:58 — #14
The hypothesis: Despite plenty of clues, We are still fucking idiots.
Tested and answered: Proven beyond any reasonable doubt.
sockdoll at October 6th, 2013 16:04 — #15
I had some shredded jellyfish on a JAL flight to Hong Kong once. I think they were also pickled or something. I had not previously encountered that texture in a food item before.
fuzzyfungus at October 6th, 2013 16:22 — #16
And that, kids, is how we learned which jellyfish species can reproduce by regrowing full adults from lost fragments...
(In all seriousness, do any of them reproduce by 'budding'? Because, if so, I suspect that shredbot-3000 is going to have an... unexpected... effect on their population.)
snig at October 6th, 2013 18:03 — #17
Wasn't this the plot of Pacific Rim?
jerry_vandesic at October 6th, 2013 18:10 — #18
Couldn't the same thing be said for the wholesale slaughter of mosquitos? The last few years have seen the introduction of some large scale mosquito killing devices. How do we draw the line?
technogeekagain at October 6th, 2013 18:20 — #19
Between global warming and humans pumping highly nutritious run-off into the oceans -- plus, quite probably, lots of other factors -- there have been significant jellyfish population booms in some waters, enough to make quite a mess of areas where humans have been fishing. And yes, our general response to a population boom in pest species has tended to be to find some way to kill them off -- introducing predators (which has its own history of problems), or trapping or poisoning or shooting.
As to whether this is a good solution or not... I haven't a clue; I don't know enough about population dynamics of the ocean food chain, and I can't judge how selective this widget really is in what it purees. And even assuming it works, I'm not sure what the release of the nutrients tied up in the jellyfish into the water will do to the population of everything else.
In a way, of course, this is another aspect of our having always assumed the oceans were too large for us to affect -- we also assumed they were too large to change much, period. But there must have been booms and busts there as on land, We may just have to accept that we don't know as much as we thought we did about what to expect, and figure out ways to adapt... and accept that in some situations we are going to be outcompeted.
tylersweeney at October 6th, 2013 20:22 — #20
thats just, a huge bummer to watch.
geekington at October 6th, 2013 21:18 — #21
The ranking of every creature on Earth doesn't go up just because dogs experience emotion; something just about anyone who has ever owned a dog could tell you. Jellyfish don't even have brains.
next page →