doctorow at October 3rd, 2013 21:00 — #1
robulus at October 3rd, 2013 22:19 — #2
Evidence led approach
Snort!!! These guys are almost as funny as the NSA!
harryjc at October 4th, 2013 02:38 — #3
I'm sure the government is fully aware of what's going on. Because they're probably benefiting.
kimmo at October 4th, 2013 03:13 — #4
I'd say the mere possibility, let alone the reality, of any three-strikes law is testament to the fact that something has been very, very wrong with democracy for a while now, and a bit of academic advice like this is nothing more than cold comfort for the victims (everyone) of an ongoing agenda.
swuwmcyl at October 4th, 2013 06:56 — #5
And all of the murders aren't killing Detroit either. There are still hundreds of thousands of people living there. So let's give up on prosecuting it because it's all just a waste of money and the people are obviously unconcerned.
The problem is that just because some crime doesn't kill something, doesn't mean we can just start openly embracing that crime. IF it's not a crime to pirate something, which suckers would pay for a work?
heng at October 4th, 2013 07:07 — #6
Something isn't wrong just because it's a crime. Generally things are crimes because they are wrong. In the case of copyright, the history is actually very interesting. I recommend this book from which you might gain a deeper understanding of why what you just said is nonsense, and a very good reply to your (I suspect rhetorical) question.
squidgyb at October 4th, 2013 08:08 — #7
Hah! "Evidence based policy"; Last time I remember that phrase being bandied around Whitehall/the press was when David Nutt was sacked...
incarnedine_v at October 4th, 2013 09:21 — #8
Evidence? You can't win an election with that, come back with a bag of money then we'll talk.
hmsgoose at October 4th, 2013 09:27 — #9
aaaand since we have limited resources and will to prevent crime, and since you astutely point out that the best kinds of murders are no murders at all, why don't we make sure that our justice system isn't manipulated and distracted from it's most pressing concerns by self-interested and dishonest industries. Or at least give them the opportunity, and freedom of capture to allow them to set proper priorities and levels of attention.
peregrinus_bis at October 4th, 2013 11:07 — #10
Oh come on.
What would the London School of Economics know about ... er ... economics? I mean, wtf?
Honestly, this has nothing to do with politics or power. It's a pure and simple story: piracy sucks the very lifeblood out of artists' hearts, and diminishes the income of investors in corporations. No-one in 8 years has bought a single cd.
Unless some kind of leash is put to the pirates, we're all doomed. Besides, they're also causing sea-levels to rise, and preventing cures for diseases that could be easily dealt with.
lynnfredricks at October 5th, 2013 17:33 — #11
If boingboing is going to copy or link articles from TorrentFreak, how about linking to the original source?
Because those industries may be doing well, that doesn't invalidate claims of harm - by them or by others. There are smaller companies and individual artists who license their designs, art, music, whatever and see their revenues drop because pirates continuously upload it to free file sharing sites. In turn, those pirates generate revenue from ad affiliate programs from ads on sites where those files are linked.
I know of hundreds of such artists affected - visit sites like deviantart, renderosity.com, meshbox.com, contentparadise.com and others like them. Creators license their products through such sites, just to see them uploaded by scumbags later.
badprofessor at October 6th, 2013 16:25 — #12
Government rarely turns down an additional excuse to monitor/jail citizens, especially once the for-profit prison scam is established.
peregrinus_bis at October 6th, 2013 17:30 — #13
Good point. I don't think anyone wants to see the smaller than big people / corporations getting hurt.
doctorow at October 8th, 2013 21:00 — #14
This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.