Catholic school to hand out ‘modesty ponchos’ to girls at prom wearing ‘revealing’ dresses

No-ooo, but they do have the right to set rules for gatherings which they are hosting, surely?

What’s being described in this article is a pathetic and disgusting example of the way in which Catholicism (among other religions) shames both female sexuality in particular and sexuality in general, and I agree it’s a profoundly shitty thing to do to anyone, but you’re drawing a very dubious analogy here.

The prom is a private gathering hosted by a private organisation on their own property, and while the whole “modesty poncho” thing is a nauseating bit of public shaming, the existence of a dress code is not some kind of monstrous evil exclusive to “religious zealots”.

Or have you never been to a restaurant that will refuse to serve you if you aren’t wearing a tie?

3 Likes

As many people told me when I semi-inadvertently made a pair “All chaps are assless” - to which my response was, “yeah, but these ones are assless”.

2 Likes

I love how libertarian arguments can so easily be turned to defend illiberalism.

3 Likes

Not if the buyer is the product of toxic masculinity, and is thus inexperienced and lacking in confidence in their own sexuality.

3 Likes

I’d have gone for something more “Handmaid’s Tale”.

I think the linked article has you covered:

No one’s saying the school doesn’t have the right to do this, but the rest of us have every right to mock administrators for their inability to let girls dress themselves.

9 Likes

Um, just on the desk panel bit. Its not for women only. As far as Ive seen, it gives the person sitting on the chair some privacy.
Typically used in banks/open offices, these provide a much needed barrier between the customer and the person on the chair.

5 Likes

Not for sexual pleasure (there were other kinds of woman for that) but for reproduction. The buyer wants to make sure that his bride is not already pregnant and that when she has children there is no possibility of anyone else being the father.

4 Likes

I might be wrong, but I would assume that Islamc schools simply don’t have events where biys and girls dance together. The very idea would be considered indecent.

In any case, not all Arabs are Muslims.

2 Likes

Libertarianism seems to be founded on the assumption that only governments can be “oppressive”, and so it easily justifies oppression by private property owners.

8 Likes

Had they tried such a stunt at my school, I’m quite sure we would have been ‘sold out’ 5 minutes after the start of the prom :smile: Every girl would have wanted one for the suggestion of being a ‘hot babe’ underneath.

There’s an update to this story:

Maybe internet outrage can occasionally make a difference?

17 Likes

Cant’ be; we’re just wasting out time being triggered by dress codes. /s

10 Likes

Are we sure it’s a poncho and not a serape (serapa in some parts)?

1 Like

Do you have her number? Asking for a friend.

3 Likes

FTFY, just to make sure that Ayn-caps only get credited for distorting an idea beyond all recognition of it’s former self, and not for originally creating it.

4 Likes

Fair enough! I meant founded as in underpinned, not as in originally created (I guess those meanings are easy to equivocate between those two since they are metaphors to buildings which are much harder to replace the foundations of than philosophies).

I’m not a libertarian by any definition, but obviously there are a wide variety of ideas/philosophies that call themselves “libertarian” and not all are about people trying to burn down society so that they can sell the ashes.

Or a drag queen. Perhaps a drag queen band!

4 Likes

As long as every one is invited.

5 Likes

Opening for Guided by Voices and Imagine Dragons.

6 Likes