Floating abortion clinic in Gulf proposed to serve patients in south

Until the next (R) president comes along and signs an executive order putting an end to that.

21 Likes

There is only a right to travel outside of one’s own State, either to another State or out of the USA, if the Supreme Court says there is. The longstanding practice, going back to before the Founding, is to deny at least some people travel without permission.

Therefore there is no such right, according to Dobbs.

17 Likes

https://amp.theguardian.com/uk/2001/jun/12/andrewosborn

Everything awful is new again.

29 Likes

Hospital ships are how medical services are provided to places suffering natural disasters. Works for unnatural disasters as well I guess.

28 Likes

A group in Texas is working on a strategy to declare that the fetus counts as a person, thus leaving the state for an abortion means transporting a minor over state lines for the purpose of committing a crime. That is grounds for denying travel and also arresting the mother when she returns. It’s a special kind of madness that I don’t have words for.

This American Life interviewed the lawyer working on this, if anyone wants to know more,

33 Likes

I really don’t want to know more. But to fight it, I also have to know more.

29 Likes

In 1939, State Attorney General Earl Warren proposed a new legal argument against offshore gambling ships. He called them “a great nuisance” because they drew millions of dollars from legitimate purposes and would inevitably lead to the appearance of floating narcotics dens and houses of prostitution. He reasoned that states had the power to abate a nuisance even if it lies outside state jurisdiction.
After failing to comply with a state order to cease and desist, all but one of the gambling ships were seized by law enforcement.

And what is to stop $10k bounties on people facilitating travel to them. Rule of law? So passe.

7 Likes

Yep. Women exercising bodily autonomy sure is “a great nuisance”… /s

13 Likes

Just imagine if those assholes used their creativity for good… I guess they wouldn’t be Republicans then.

Edited to include negative. Thanks to @ClutchLinkey

10 Likes

It’s not nothing, but for women who live away from the coast, the issue of “how to get there” still remains. I imagine that this will become just one part of a whole underground railroad to get women to safety.

If it comes to that, may the stations be many and the conductors fearless.

10 Likes

Do you mean “wouldn’t”?

8 Likes

Is anyone else morbidly pondering the upcoming ‘originalist’ explanation for how crossing the US border to do business in international waters is actually a matter for the states?

6 Likes

Tony Cornero, the eccentric mobster “admiral” of the Santa Monica gambling fleet, was an accomplished amateur maritime lawyer who was a thorn in Earl Warren’s side for years. Warren finally had to resort to this shoddy “nuisance” argument after being outsmarted on matters like where the mooring lines were anchored.

I’m sure that the abortion providers will have professional maritime as well as other attorneys covering them. I’m equally sure that the handmaid states will pull their own versions of Warren’s morality-based argument (and of the L.A. D.A.'s dubiously legal seaborne piracy raids). I’m pretty confident that the former group, with the support of the ACLU, will put up a strong enough fight to make this plan worth trying.

7 Likes

Me. By whatever means necessary.

22 Likes

The distribution is considerably different in the US(much lower percentage of self-identified catholics in the general population; but a combination of representation where it counts and the adoption of a number of points of traditionally catholic theology by evangelical protestants who recognize the need to actually have a theology, even if most of it is just Aristotle with the serial numbers filed off and misogynistically annotated); but there’s a lot of commonality the situations.

5 Likes

It’s all about the Baptists & Evangelicals in Texas.

12 Likes

And of course, when all the other groups that they hate are subjugated, the evangelicals and baptists will once again focus on Catholics as outsiders. MTG has already made some anti-Catholic statements, so its coming sooner rather than later.

15 Likes

Oh, I absolutely agree in terms of popular religious affiliation and where the footsoldiers are coming from; my point was just that the intellectual backing on the judicial side (and, to the degree that they even need reasons, the basis for theological arguments in favor of a position that was promoted from minimal relevance to central article of faith for evangelicals in the relative blink of an eye).

It’s absolutely not the case that a groundswell of catholic laity is the driving force(though Latin American immigration in the area is probably helping them lose market share more slowly there than they are in other locations); but the theological underpinnings of seeing abortion as a big serious sin because of ‘natural law’, rather than just a property issue as a plain reading of Exodus 21:22 suggests, are very much a catholic thing; aided by the fact that catholics actually have an exhaustively articulated and chewed over theology to work with, which can prove attractive to some of the smarter evangelicals.

1 Like

A fetus cannot survive on its own, nor does it have self-awareness. The Christian Taliban might as well declare cancer a person, too.

2 Likes

For people living on the Gulf coast this might help, but the logistics would be very difficult. The same reason it would help (all surrounding states have forced-birth laws) makes supplying an offshore clinic a difficult task. Any abortifacient drugs would likely have to be brought by boat >500 miles from the nearest sane state (do we have a term for non-forced-birth states?).

A much more effective, better solution would be putting public clinics on federal land

7 Likes