I am all for handling people with style and grace (and having fun), but I donāt want BBS to become a gladitorial arena for combat, even if we are on the right side.
I donāt think itās at any risk of becoming that at all. Consider what sort of threads attract these particular kind of trollies. Look at how many comments this discussion alone has garnered, compared to other sorts of topics being discussed here, and also the number of obvious and possible trollies compared to other threads. Iād like to see THAT sort of data.
Any thread having to do with feminism and any thread specifically having to do with GamerGate and, now, this stupid Puppies bullshit, gets a lot of comments, and I would be willing to bet way more driving trollies than most other subjects here. The same goes for issues having to do with race (such as the Baltimore riots). Thatās also of course going to get a lot of attention.
But the subjects of GamerGate and Puppies stuff specifically have trollies completely dedicated to seeking out threads having to do with those subjects and then driving trollies them. Just as this Hugo Award shit-show was planned, so are many of these driving trollies sprees They hang out in their own (terrible) forums, and on reddit and 4chan etc. These arenāt just random trollies with individual motives, like most other trollies you might see.
Thereās a reason they tend to happen in waves, and when one goes another almost immediately follows. I am always suspicious when two noobs come in only a few hours within the same day in the same or related threads
This happens over at PZ Myerās blog all the time with slymepitters.
Also, Anti-choicers have been known to infiltrate blogs and online communities with their own brand of driving trollies.
Do you note a pattern? I do.
(And seriously, some of these sci-fi writers referenced above are horrible people, based on some of the things they have published. Awful. Embarrassing. Indefensible. I am literally sorry I clicked through to read about them.)
And some of them have actual fucking influence. And fans. Who trolley threads just like these. Iām pretty sure this is what @chenille was alluding to in her reply to you in the trolley thread.
Itās a festering wound, @codinghorror, and festering wounds donāt just heal if you ignore them. They get worse. Until your entire leg rots and falls off.