The Badge would presumably have been for this one in the Lounge that got 10 likes overnight, but that should be a “Nice Reply” instead of a “Nice Share”:
maybe the second doesn’t preview because it goes to the Lounge? while the first is in Meta category, so is open to the public to see?
IIRC I posted the same thing once about receiving a Nice Share badge, and it was explained to me but I have forgotten the explanation. I found it counter-intuitive. I have recently been thinking of asking that it be clarified. Glad you have brought it up.
I’ve been confused by this before myself. You got the nice share for linking to the post from “.gif Bank for the BBS”:
When you earn the badge, it shows the post you linked to, not your post. I assume the idea is that the original post is what you are “sharing” by creating the link.
I don’t think any of the posts in the lounge category contribute to stats. If you go to the post in the Hillary Clinton thread, your link to the .gif thread is listed right below the post.