QVC host and guest debate whether Earth's moon is a planet or a star

I wouldn’t say that it’s correct.

https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/news/2006/08/17/what-is-a-binary-planet

Although Pluto-Charon is the only recognized binary planet in the solar system, there are binary asteroids and binary Kuiper Belt Objects. Of course, there are also many binary stars in the galaxy as well. New Horizons is expected to be the first mission to visit any kind of binary object.

The barycenter of the earth-moon system lies within the radius of the earth-- so it’s not a double planet.

5 Likes

This. If the spokeswoman had just said, “If you’ve ever tried to imagine what vomit looks like in shades of different colors, well here you go!” instead of comparing these paint smocks to heavenly bodies, we could have avoided this whole embarrassing conversation.

2 Likes

Surely that is semiotics. Oregon State University

I know it’s impossible to fight against popular changes to languages. But sometimes it seems worth trying to stop all words meaning the same.

2 Likes

Saying “it’s all just semantics” when you mean “it’s all just semiotics” is a semantic mistake. But the reverse isn’t true. :confused:

12 Likes

I am suddenly proud of the fact that I don’t watch QVC.

3 Likes

I thought it was Errant Spelling, therefore - Yes! - of course.

:wink:

1 Like

I actually have had people present a limestone concretion to me as a meteorite, as well as a terrestrial rock ‘because God told them it was from Mars!’ There does seem to be some confusion about what a meteorite is, although I don’t know what questions you ran into.

Freddie Mercury was a wildly successful star until his light was so tragically extinguished. Does that count for anything?

3 Likes

Wait, isn’t there a song that helps kids remember this stuff?

4 Likes

Awww… I thought I was going to get to be the one to point it out this time!

Hmmm, I went through 90 comments expecting to see the “Why not both” meme. Surprised I didn’t see it.

2 Likes

Sincerest apologies to all beauty pageant contestants.

There’s a moon in the sky
It’s called the moon
And everybody is there, including,
Saturn, Mercury
Saturn, Venus
Saturn, Mars
Saturn, Jupiter
The Van Allen Belt

No, I think that would just further confuse these guys.

1 Like

Their conversation makes total sense when viewed from the angle that they must be super stoned.

2 Likes

A fussy patron of the paranormal, Mizrahi chooses his psychics as carefully as his fabrics. “There’s my astrologer, Maria Napoli, who I’ve been seeing since I was eighteen. I go to her every six months for a checkup, like you would a doctor.” But since getting an appointment with Napoli is as difficult as getting into the Oscars, Mizrahi also recommends Tony LeRoy. “I see him for tarot readings two or three times a year. He’s a real optimist.”

1 Like

Using meteor, meteorite, and meteoroid interchangeably.

AHA! but since EITHER the earth OR the moon would dynamically dominate the 1 AU orbit if it were here by itself, and since in reality BOTH such planetary bodies ARE here together in the same orbit, therefore it IS a double planet!

3 Likes

wikipedia suggest five different definitions.

my favorite definition (barycenter), which I can cling to because I’m not an astronomer, and enjoy being pedantically difficult, has the interesting side effect of making Jupiter a double “star” with the “sun”. Yeah. That’s the kind of contradiction I can get behind, baby!

2 Likes

After a few days I finally forced myself to watch the video.

This image is perfect.

2 Likes