Substitute fine old rums for bourbon and save


Barbancourt 15 and Zacapa 23 are both excellent. I would add Mount Gay Extra Old, and Doorly’s XO (an almost sherry-like rum), as other rums worth drinking that won’t do too much damage to your wallet.

1 Like

SSSSSHHHHH!!! Ix-nay on the Acapa-Zay. The fewer people that know about that, the better!


Rum is still a little sweeter than most whiskey though, so (depending on the sprit it used) I’d say go light on the sugar when making mixed drinks with it.

While I’m a big fan of the Rum Which Dare Not Be Named, and drink that over ice*, I will say the El Dorado is a big bargain - I think the 12 year is like half the price of the Z- and is still good enough to be enjoyed on its own and great in mixed drinks. The 15 year offers no significant improvement, if I remember correctly. One note though; I believe that rums use a different standard for their aging - when the bottle says 15 years, it doesn’t mean all of the rum inside has been aged that long, but that some of the rum has been aged that long. That’s what I remember from a tour of a rum factory in Barbados a few years ago, anyway.

*Here’s my personal recipe for a cocktail I call The Mid-Life Crisis; pour 3 oz of the 23-year old rum of your choosing over ice, mix with equal parts nostalgia and regret, and garnish with a sprig of mint. Enjoy!

EDIT: after doing some research, it would seem that some rums, including El Dorado, list the age of the youngest rum in the bottle, which is the same standard as whiskey. In other words, a bottle of 12 year El Dorado will contain a blend of rum not younger than 12 years old. Other rums use the “solera” method, which blends rum of different ages and which may use the age of the oldest rum in the blend. Think of it as the homeopathy of distillation. Zacapa uses this method, which may explain why (IMO) the quality has gone down as availability has expanded.


Different spirits go up and down in popularity, and there’s some serious savings to be had. Rum is also in a bit of a revival right now, but it’s mostly in young, spiced/flavoured rums. It’s hard to find any that you could call ‘old’ around here.

My recommendation for budget spirits: Brandy. It’s been unpopular for a while now, and you can pick up some shockingly good stuff on the cheap.

1 Like

Substitute rum for your fancy-pants bourbon and drive prices up? No way. You leave my rum the fuck alone…


For pity’s sake, don’t let people know about good rum, you’ll ruin it for the rest of us!

Next thing you know you’ll let people know that blended Scotch can be as good or better than single malt, and cheaper.

That El Dorado rum - it’s a long story but we have a few bottles of that stuff. It is indeed much more like bourbon than the sweet rums that are more popular. It’s got a bite. I’m not the hugest fan but I prefer it to Bacardi for sure.

Rum is already the rage, hell there are rum bars in Tucson, AZ, so, a little late to the party.

More to the point, if you can interchange rum and bourbon in your drinks without noticing, you shouldn’t be wasting good money on either. Not a judgement, just financial advice.

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.