"The Pout-Pout Fish" is a truly terrible childrens' book series for teaching about consent and mental health

Avoid “The Wonky Donkey” at all costs. Unless you want to see a horrible example of making fun of those with disabilities. We got it as a gift. I read it once and trashed it. It was so offensive, I didn’t even want to donate it to our local Little Free Library.

We have a 3-year-old and also like “Giraffes Can’t Dance” in terms of learning about being more accepting of differences. I found the “Little Blue Truck” series good as well – no major social justice lessons, but LBT is friendly with all sorts of animals and helps those in need. The Maisy the Mouse series and Pete the Cat series also are good from the few books I’ve seen. My son was obsessed with “Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See” for long time and is now on to “The Very Hungry Caterpillar.” “Harold and the Purple Crayon” also is a bit trippy, which I like (and it got a reference in the TV show “Legion”). I have some minor issues with some of the little details in these books, but nothing major (e.g., the caterpillar is called “fat” but I think it’s done in a descriptive, non-judgmental way and it’s part of the process of him becoming a butterfly).

By the way, we have leaned towards the thicker “board books” these first few years since it was easier for us to turn the pages while holding him in one arm, and now that he’s older he can turn the pages himself.

A friend gave us “A is for Activist,” which is fantastic, but probably best for a bit older than our kiddo. Same thing for Ezra Jack Keats books – love 'em, and they will be great in another year or two.

(By the way, our only kiddo was born 6 weeks early and spent 10 days in the NICU. It’s a difficult, unexpected way to become a parent. He is now a smart, joyful little boy who still does things on his own timeline, regardless of how much stress or panic it creates in his parents. Best of luck to you and your family. :slight_smile: )

4 Likes

tumblr_p8c34wJVaE1wp7qxyo1_400

24 Likes

Ok. I couldn’t resist. Jane Yolen’s How Do Dinosaurs books are delightful. The rhymes will get stuck in your head. There are board book versions of many of them and every chid I’ve read them to loves saying “Noooo!” at thr end of every dinosaur misbehavior.
https://www.janeyolen.com/how-do-dinosaurs-say-goodnight/

Books are serious businesa at our house.

8 Likes

Because it’s never to early to teach kids about “resting bitch face” or to avoid those that look different than you?

13 Likes

A terrific new book about having consideration and respect for all sentient beings, and also features a fish, is “An Underwater Friend”: https://fishfeel.org/an-underwater-friend/ This beautifully illustrated book "makes the reader aware that we all have feelings, and that we should treat everyone, including our animal friends, as we would want to be treated: with respect and compassion.”

3 Likes

Uhhhh what was your professor’s reasoning for it being a “good” children’s book?

Sure, I will confess: the art is cute and fun, the rhymes are good and catchy (too catchy), and it’s easy to read with basically one line per cardboard page. But the same can be said of a lot of kid’s books…

9 Likes

A lot of people forget that books, like any other kind of media, are 95% absolute garbage and plagued by tons of churned-out, lazy sequels. Childrens’ books are no exception- if anything, they’re held to a lower standard. Be very discerning in what you buy for your kids. Put in the time to make sure you’re sending them the right messages, because society sure isn’t interested in doing it.

10 Likes

Rob recommended a good one a few years back:

14 Likes

Topher Payne has some great Fix it endings to problematic children’s books. They include The Rainbow Fish (keeps his scales), The Giving Tree (A Tree that Sets Healthy Boundaries) and he just added I’ll Love You Forever (& Next Time I’ll Call First). They are a great antidote to these books.

12 Likes

In terms of board books (which are great for any age that tends to grab at pages with something like animal enthusiasm) Sandra Boynton has a whole series of board books that are funny, irreverent, and have good art. Their humor slides nicely into the “Sesame Street” range, where it’s silly and rhythmic enough for even sub-vocal toddlers to get, but still charming and clever enough for adults to not drive them absolutely insane. Our favorites include:

Barnyard Dance
Blue Hat, Green Hat (the oops book)
The Bedtime Book, and
… But not the Hippopotamus

edited to include The Bellybutton Book.

10 Likes

Peter H. Reynolds - ish, the Dot, sky colour
Herve Tullet - Press here, and others
Kate Beaton - The Princess and the Pony
Peek-A-Who? - Nina Laden

6 Likes

How could I forget about her? Hippos Go Berserk is our favorite. She also has a few bath books.

5 Likes

The Boynton albums are likewise enjoyable with a panoply of artists singing things you’ll enjoy.

Sandra Boynton’s Frog Trouble https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00CZAYL58

4 Likes

You know this is my dream thread, right?

Board Books:

Everywhere Babies
~ Susan Meyers (ill. Marla Frazee)

Don’t Push the Button
Don’t Touch This Book
Happy Face Sad Face
Little Face Big Face
~ Bill Cotter

I am a Bunny
~ Ole Risum (ill. Richard Scarry)

How do Dinosaurs Play With Their Friends?
~ Jane Yolen & Mark Teague

Picture Books

Knufflebunny
Don’t Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus
My Friend is Sad
We Are in a Book!
~ or anything by Mo Willems

Ox Cart Man
~ Donald Hall (ill Barbara Cooney!!!)
My all-time favorite

Miss Rumphius
~ Barbara Cooney
Mrs Peas all-time favorite

Frog and Toad Through the Year
Frog and Toad are Friends (even though Frog acts like a bit of a butthole at one point, it portrays an enduring, strong male friendship)
~ Arnold Lobel

Baseball Saved Us
~ Ken Mochizuki

Lifetimes
~ Bryan Mellonie & Robert Ingpen
As the subtitle states: “A beautiful way to explain death to children”
See also: The Dead Bird by Margaret Wise Brown (her most coherent and thoughtful book by far)

All the World
~ Liz Garton Scanlon (ill Marla Frazee)

Home
~ Carson Ellis

The Quilt
~ Ann Jonas

Amazing Grace
~ Mary Hoffman

Corduroy
~ Don Freeman

Sulwe
~ Lupita Nyong’o (yes, that Lupita Nyong’o)

And, of course:

Where the Wild Things Are
In the Night Kitchen
Outside Over There (pretty freaky, so maybe when they’re older)
~ Maurice Sendak

All of these are thoughtful books oriented to a child’s perception devoid of any problematic elements (except Frog being a little thoughtless). One thing I find in children’s lit, especially pre-K, is that most writers assume that little ones are simply in need of entertainment and not intellectual nourishment. In fact, they are more in need of the intellectual component of literature than adults, IMO. Little ones are grappling with thoughts and emotions that are REALLY BIG (just as big as yours!) and don’t yet have a way to contextualize them or themselves as an individual. They may not think about death or the afterlife as an adult would, but they certainly notice when a bug isn’t moving anymore or that a rock never did. Or when their parents are sad… or fighting… or loving them.

The best writers understand this inherently and write to their audience as opposed to their parents (the best write to both). The greats do this while also teaching about empathy and profound social issues.

Congratulations and best wishes with everything! Don’t forget to focus on your primary relationship. Remember that she has been through a brutal physical, emotional and spiritual shift. Take care of yourself, too! It will help you both navigate the next few years.

When you’re ready for early readers and chapter books hit me up!

12 Likes

And, most topically, “Happy Hippo, Angry Duck”.

A number of her books have been set to music, and recorded by people like…Kevin Bacon.

https://www.sandraboynton.com/sboynton/boyntonmusic.html

My wife, and her side of the family, all loved “Pout Pout Fish”. I abominate stories where the answer to being sad is to just smile more, dumbass, and the “Pout Pout Fish” is only the latest in a long, long line of that shit, often from authors who are otherwise entertaining. Also, the idea that if you are just mopey enough the hot girl will come and totally be into you is especially disturbing to me.

Also, my favorite Simpsons episode:

3 Likes

Rabbit’s treatment of Kanga and Roo, and Tigger as Unwanted Foreigners is pretty dodgy, but he does get his comeuppance.

The other surprising thing I found is that most people identify with one character, but often a different one. I identified with the eponymous bear, and guess this was universal; but my sister was Tigger. There was Christopher Robin, the human, but none of us thought of us as him.

4 Likes

One of my son’s favorite books throughout childhood was Dinosaur Roar by Henrietta and Paul Stickland. If you are willing to go all out on voicing, it’s really fun!

1 Like

Favorite kids books that have good messaging:

Perfect Square - Michael Hall

One - Kathryn Otoshi

Mama, Do you love me?
Papa, Do you love me? - Barbara Joose/Barbara Lavallee

Love Monster - Rachel Bright

2 Likes

Hippos Go Berserk

————
Also
Each Peach Pear Plum. by Janet and Allan Ahlberg

3 Likes

One more - My No No No Day is perhaps a better alternative to Il Pescado Pout-Pout.

2 Likes