This Day in Blogging History: Four Men in Hats puzzle; White supremacists for Obama; Mieville on Tolkien


#1

[Permalink]


#2

Oh, China Mieville, you so self-righteous.


#3

self righteous and unable to keep a page up for even a decade …


#4

Why would you link to a story from ten years ago with a broken link? Why not do us the favour of linking to the Way Back Machine or some cached/pirated copy?

https://web.archive.org/web/20040208073027/http://www.panmacmillan.com/features/china/debate.htm


#5

Lemme go one further, in fact: fantasy/sci-fi writers who self-righteously despise escapism need to open their eyes. There is nothing wrong with escapism, just as there’s nothing wrong with transcending escapism.

Discuss.


#6

Well, reading his essay I would say that he doest despises escapism, what he despises is that mainstream fantasy has relied too much in safe escapism, setting aside any challenge, any surprise.
I find his critic of mainstream fantasy quite similar to the critical response to the safe, formulaic view of modern Hollywood cinema.
Long story short: you can have escapism AND blow minds at the same time.


#7

This topic was automatically closed after 8 days. New replies are no longer allowed.