Originally published at: https://boingboing.net/2020/10/12/watch-a-dog-play-the-shell-game.html
…
good boy!
SHILL!
Not to denigrate that dog (who I’m sure is indeed a genius and a very good boy), but I don’t think the human is very good at the shell game.
Smart and cute!
The dog isn’t looking at the cups, so this is likely a Clever Hans type effect where the dog is reading the person to tell which cup to pick
You may be right. Dogs can read human body language, facial expression & gaze much better than humans. The human isn’t even aware he is giving it away. That, plus the smell of the treat
If this dog is the breed I think it is, then the odds are good the dog is pretty smart.
Well, yeah, all dogs…
Yeah, the guy handles the block with the same hand he uses to pass over the treat, so, I assume, there will be some treat smell on the block.
It’s cute but…
1st) The human never shows there’s nothing under all 3 cups cups at the same time (as in, all 3 cups are never revealed to be empty at the same time) and, out of 3 games, the dog only picks cups in 2 positions.
2nd) I don’t know if we ever see the side of the cups the dog sees (I don’t feel like examining) so a cup may be marked.
3rd) The human blocks the cups & his handling of them, a lot, from the camera with his body/bulky sweater.
It doesn’t seem the dog is smelling/investigating at all - so it’s either all the cups have shells and the dog just has to knock over a cup -or- two cups have shells and the dog knows to knock over the middle or right cup -or- the shelled cup is marked -or- the person is cueing the dog out of camera sight.
Again, it’s a cute vid but I hope we can we all agree the dog is not “winning” the shell game on its own.
This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.