Why isn't fish considered meat during Lent?

Not as bad as being allergic to corn.

5 Likes

As someone from a region where carp ponds have been a common, and mostly church-owned, way of land use since the high, possibly the early, Middle Ages I had to chuckle. Not that you’re wrong per se, reality is just always more complicated.

8 Likes

Especially when you consider the sheer number of non-meat days observed in the Middle Ages.

I always saw that as a result of fish being further removed from us evolutionarily than other animals that are commonly eaten. By that logic, reptile meat should also be fine.

2 Likes

I remember a trivia event I was at and the question was something along the lines of “What type of meat is eaten the most?” I put down fish. Which was incorrect according to the organiser, as fish isn’t meat.

2 Likes

And octopus should be even more OK, as it’s not even in the same phylum.

I’ll eat fish, but I won’t eat octopus.

1 Like

I doubt there is a salmon river in the entire PNW that doesn’t have a spot called “the meat hole.”

3 Likes

I learned the term fishing the Upper Snoqualmie in WA almost 40 years ago!

3 Likes

image

4 Likes

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.