#1 By: Rob Beschizza, October 22nd, 2013 10:01
#2 By: Jardine, October 22nd, 2013 10:07
#3 By: Omri Schwarz, October 22nd, 2013 10:10
I'd like to see something done the opposite way, with full out overdetailed late Medieval heraldry for each state.
#4 By: Mellivora Capensis, October 22nd, 2013 10:24
- Use meaningful symbolism.
(How relevant is the Confederate Flag?)
I'm not sure if the naiveté is touching or discouraging.
#5 By: JesticHuds, October 22nd, 2013 10:30
I think New Mexico would be very, very unhappy with this.
The Zia should be red - not white. Maybe this would work if each flag was still designed by a resident of each state - but this just looks like New England puked on ever other states flags...
Also - doesn't this kinda deny each states a long established facet of their unique identities?
#6 By: Mellivora Capensis, October 22nd, 2013 10:32
I want that.
Meanwhile, Mr. Graphic Design Genius made his California flag uber-suXX0rz.
#7 By: Hangle E. Mann, October 22nd, 2013 10:45
While I can sort of understand the unified concept he was going for, sucking away any color that isn't red, white or blue makes the flags astoundingly boring, and making everything look like a stylized logo makes it appear more like a collection of gas station brands than state flags.
#8 By: Mellivora Capensis, October 22nd, 2013 10:51
Perfect, that's exactly what they are.
#9 By: Ranger G, October 22nd, 2013 11:27
Those colors haven't felt modern since the early nineties. old glory's are so much nicer.
couldn't he just use the 'offset path' on connecticut's flag instead of a 12pt stroke?
#10 By: Mike B, October 22nd, 2013 11:27
...making everything look like a stylized logo makes it appear more like a collection of gas station brands than state flags.
Gas station brands indeed. Or airline logos. Taken individually, most of them are just bad. Taken as a group, they pretty much eliminate any point of having a state flag at all, since they all look basically the same, and most don't even have a single distinctive element that you could throw on a hat or a T-shirt or what have you. Looking at the four states I've lived in:
New York: OK, New York's current flag is just the seal on a blue field, which is awful, but look at this new one. I understand the urge to put the Statue of Liberty's crown on there, but if we're going for unity, we shouldn't antagonize New Jersey, which has a long-standing feud with New York over what state the statue is in. And those red and white borders on two sides would look nice on a brochure for health insurance, but they don't belong on this flag. And great, throw in a red star just because. What?
Pennsylvania: Also a terrible current flag, sure. But here, "A nib of a pen occupies the lefthand side, representing the signing of the Declaration of Independence." A pen? Seriously? Not the Liberty Bell, not Independence Hall, but a pen? And the red stars make it look too much like the flag of Chicago. And again with extraneous elements. Why the blue line? Is it a river?
California: I cannot even begin to explain how bad the new one is. If one were to change California's flag, the thing to do would be to remove the text and maybe simplify the bear a bit, but it's a pretty recognizable flag that doesn't need a complete overhaul into blandness and abstract symbolism.
South Carolina: This one is one of the greatest tragedies of the bunch. South Carolina's current flag is iconic within the state. It's everywhere. It's on beach chairs, it's on beer coozies, everywhere. Because it's already pretty simple and symbolic, it's unique to the state, and it looks good. The new one has all of the problems of the others, but with the added crime of throwing out almost everything that makes the current flag great.
#11 By: Ranger G, October 22nd, 2013 11:31
"The blue represents the great Salt Lake and the smaller blue bars are the lesser lakes."
Because Utah is known for it's "lesser lakes"? and not a single mountain! c'mon utah is 'Best Snow on Earth!"
#12 By: WhyBother, October 22nd, 2013 11:34
Ed Mitchell is more clever than we give him credit for. He's united everyone against him.
#13 By: WhyBother, October 22nd, 2013 11:35
Check out the Maryland flag.
As a bonus, it makes for some of the most awesomely busy uniforms in college football.
#14 By: Steve B, October 22nd, 2013 11:42
I agree. The old-school Revolutionary symbolism of the current flag's cool ( and almost shocking for the first state to secede from the Union). I'll give the new one that it tries to keep the same theme... and fails. Using Revolutionary War uniform components may have seemed like a good idea, but when I first saw it, I thought the crescent and star were the Islamic symbols. Reading the description reveled that I was wrong, but I'd be surprised if I were the only one. I can hear the battle cries of 'Yankee, Commie, and Islamic' now.
#15 By: Drew Wellman, October 22nd, 2013 11:44
All this red, white, and blue with stars, stripes, and circles reminds me less of the Stars and Stripes and more of the flag of North Korea.
#16 By: Maggie Koerth-Baker, October 22nd, 2013 11:48
The Kansas flag looks particularly like a gas station logo. Dislike. "Ad Astra Per Aspera", bitches.
#17 By: Boundegar, October 22nd, 2013 11:48
This isn't exactly the most practical project. I find myself wondering if somebody paid him to do this, or if it's a side project.
#18 By: Joe Rodgers, October 22nd, 2013 12:19
Sure, the state flags suck, but that's why the outline of each state's borders are used instead. Except for Colorado, which has the most boring outline possible. So they've got a really good state flag.
#19 By: Suzanne, October 22nd, 2013 12:24
I agree. I liked a couple of his ideas, though. Like the standardized size relative to the American flag. I also liked the idea of drawing on geography. I think his designs were just too bland; I think you could use the same sorts of shapes he proposed but make the actual design of them more appealing - like the mountain could be a triangle but it could be a more interesting triangle.
#20 By: Tim, October 22nd, 2013 12:25
Grizzly bears kick ass, but I suppose one could argue that we Californians don't really deserve to have one on our flag anymore since we (or at least our forebearers) shot them all.
next page →