frauenfelder — 2014-03-25T19:17:37-04:00 — #1
picofarad — 2014-03-25T19:30:17-04:00 — #2
Have to give it 2 1/2 meh.
mrscience — 2014-03-25T20:02:02-04:00 — #3
Not bad for mirroring the work of his that becomes popular. Trent is an amazing artist that has a wide variety... My personal favorite of his is A Warm Place, and his Ghosts albums were rather unique.
funruly — 2014-03-25T20:22:50-04:00 — #4
A good goof doesn't diminish Trent's coolness.
nsted — 2014-03-25T20:23:22-04:00 — #5
duncancreamer — 2014-03-25T20:28:26-04:00 — #6
Is the interlacing intended or does Trent make that mistakes with his videos too?
robulus — 2014-03-25T21:04:11-04:00 — #7
Is Trent Reznor really a great target for this treatment? Certainly a lot of his stuff uses and subverts standard pop devices, but then this parody is doing the same (independently of its capacity as a parody), and to great effect. It is very well done.
I dunno, here's something by Mr. Reznor to chew over while contemplating how formulaic and insubstantial his work is.
innerpartisan — 2014-03-25T21:42:47-04:00 — #8
I don't think this parody is trying to make the point that Reznor's music is "formulaic and insubstantial". It's rather quite affectionate, I'd say.
robulus — 2014-03-25T22:03:55-04:00 — #9
Yeah? I find it pretty hard to read it that way.
brian_bishop — 2014-03-25T22:27:07-04:00 — #10
That's exactly how I viewed it. Obviously it's possible that it's mockery, but I'd like to think it's the work of a fan.
robulus — 2014-03-25T22:54:45-04:00 — #11
OK... so the analysis of the work as repeatable by following a set of basic steps doesn't characterise it as formulaic? And further, easily repeatable and lacking in substance?
Frankly if I had to take a crack at their motives I'd say they were after a truckload of publicity on the back of Reznor's reputation and shielded by Fair Use.
Edit: It is probably a light hearted and well intended jab. I just think its a well executed jab that unfortunately misses the target.
jerwin — 2014-03-25T23:43:17-04:00 — #12
piratejenny — 2014-03-25T23:44:19-04:00 — #13
My vote is for affectionate parody. NIN has been my favorite band for lo these many years, and I think this is quite funny. I'd like to think TR would laugh at it too--now. Maybe not 20 years ago
leviathant — 2014-03-25T23:46:10-04:00 — #14
Freddy's pretty clearly coming from a place of love with this parody, in a way that older parodies in a similar vein never really expressed. And yeah, the interlacing's on purpose, each of the scenes in this video are patterned after older NIN videos. While I kind of think putting it up on iTunes a few months after he originally debuted this is kind of stretching it, I bet they had a lot of fun making the video.
newliminted — 2014-03-26T01:15:16-04:00 — #15
ianmcloud — 2014-03-26T02:42:36-04:00 — #16
The original BB post (which isn't linked here...) made it clear that the makers of the song/video are big fans (or at least claim to be).
I'm a fan, I have been since I was 12 in the nineties, and I believe this isn't mean-spirited.
If you're too cool to laugh at light-hearted jokes at your own expense, you aren't that cool.
ianmcloud — 2014-03-26T03:06:04-04:00 — #17
Amazing song; I'd never seen this video. Like most songs, I like it better without a video.
Also, this video (and song) seem to fit with the parody pretty well.
jerwin — 2014-03-26T03:11:17-04:00 — #18
ianmcloud — 2014-03-26T03:15:58-04:00 — #19
Ah, it wasn't the original post that I was remembering, but this comment in that thread:
purplestater — 2014-03-26T06:43:16-04:00 — #20
I'd have to say that it's better than a Trent Reznor song, because I don't think that I've managed to listen to any Trent Reznor song in it's entirety, but I did this. But it's probably more likely that I just don't like Trent Reznor songs where Trent is doing the singing.
next page →