Additional categories for the bbs


#1

It was suggested by @ActionAbe in the thread: [Does BoingBoing still boing, or just thud][1] to have additional categories:

Similar points were raised by a few others in the same thread, but the discussion mostly headed elsewhere: How to handle new and clueless users(hey!). In earlier threads on the same topic* it seems that the main opposition has been the difficulty in adding categories before you know what content will be there. However I think the problem goes both ways, because at least as a new user it’s very hard to know what sort of content is appropriate.

I’m sorry if i’m rehashing an endlessly beaten discussion and that’s why the point was largely ignored.

*Best feature ever, thank you @codinghorror

PS: Why can’t I do a minor edit: turning a bullet point into a footnote as intended?
[1]: Does BoingBoing still boing, or just thud?


#2

It probably reads as too small of a change. There does not seem to be a simple way to “trick” the system into allowing a small edit.


#3

Small edits work fine. Whitespace only edits may be problematic.

As for categorization, I agree completely @ActionAbe and @adament. Please do suggest some categories, I think BBS is overdue for something more nuanced (and as you noted, more helpful to people attempting to actually create new topics) than “Boing Boing” and “Everything Else”.

(technically there is meta but meta to me is a default category that should apply to every Discourse forum, forever, like the air you breathe, it is just there.)

So, maybe a good starting point is to browse the existing topics in uncategorized and take a stab at roughly grouping them into maybe 4 or 5 broad buckets by name?

http://bbs.boingboing.net/category/uncategorized


#4

I nominate tech news, crafting, tabloidesque, fandom, and soc-pol (sociopolitical). Sauce it up as necessary. I’ve had the requisite booze and judgment is duly impaired.


#5

Adding to @Ignatius

Cute (There has to be a place for cat pictures.
Media (books and movies etc.)
Advice? Maybe?
Gaming
Look ma! (As in “Look ma! I did/made a thing.”)


#6

I kind of envisioned fandom as a place for media discussions and crafting for the “look ma” sort of things. Not sold on my names, was just throwing ideas out. XD In fact, we could call the fandom section “media” and the crafting section “look ma” (look ma is an epic name for a crafting section).

I’d just feel bad if we ended up with redundant sections because I was too drunk to make much sense.


#7

Looks like we now have

  • meta
  • dizzy
  • boing (renamed from boing boing)
  • games
  • wrath
  • files
  • links
  • craft

… so far. http://bbs.boingboing.net/categories

Note that the first post in the topic category is used for the description of the category, so the first para of that first post is significant in helping others understand what the category is for.

And “what the category is for” can be discussed by replying to the category definition topic.

(we do not, sadly, have a group “take this action on all these topics” function yet so recategorizing is a one by one affair at the moment, my apologies @beschizza)


#8

Dyin’ to see WTF “Dizzy” is about. Still has no posts or description.


#9

Huh. That’s weird. I see posts in it (though no description). Can’t create posts directly to it. Doesn’t seem to be related to any metrics I can see, doesn’t seem to have any Boing Boing posts … by process of elimination, I think it’s otherwise uncategorized posts.


#10

I take it discussions can still be in only one topic at a time… Oh well, we also don’t get to tag indivdual comments, and no fixed system deals well with fractal reality.


#11

What about the new dizzy (uncategorized) topic

Fukushima nuclear plant - steam rising - Should we be concerned?

Maybe a news type category for current events?


#12

How about a memento Mori category to post RIP threads in?


#13

When viewing “all categories”, I see a categories button to the right of favorites. When viewing a specific category, I do not see it. Why not?


#14

I think because the category drop down has an “all categories” entry at the top?


#15

But that does not actually lead me to this page: http://bbs.boingboing.net/categories


#16

The subcategory support (and the category having its own new and latest) is relatively new, so I am not sure. The rest of the team decided on that. I will have to ask.


#17

I understand having something that shows all posts (which seems to be what the “all categories” entry in the category drop down list does), but it would be nice to have easy access to the link I just posted. That way you can look to see which categories have new stuff posted, and then decide which category you want to go to (or ignore).


#18

You can already see that at any time by clicking or tapping the “hamburger” menu in the upper right:

Note the numbers next to each category which will include new and unread counts as applicable.

(Also it is subtle but clicking or tapping the word categories there will take you to the categories page.)


#19

More soon.

Dizzy is the “everything-else” one. Probably “Stuff” would be a better title. Or maybe “Sloth”. But now I kind of like having a Dizzy forum. Boing Boing has a long, proud history of advocating intoxication.

“Meta” should probably stay meta, but I would like a 5-character word that fits. “Forum” (geddit?) would be entirely too clever and confusing. So I’m thinking “House”


#20

“trash”, “waste”, or “/null” ?