Congress: Are you spying on us? NSA: We don't spy on you except to the extent that we spy on everydamnbody


#1

[Permalink]


#2

If a Congressman has to ask if you're spying on Congress, then your commitment to transparency with Congress is an obvious failure.

Sounds like NSA transparency is more akin to: "But Mr Dent, the plans have been available in the local planning office for the last nine months."


#3

There's only one thing wrong with that reasoning:

I'm sorry, that information is classified.


#4

I'd like to think there are a few hundred sour stomachs in Congress this weekend, caused by the realization that a lot of extramarital affairs, drug habits, and dead hookers have been extensively documented.


#5

On the upside: Currently Members of Congress only have the same privacy protections as all US persons, rather than some kind of elevated privacy akin to TSA's 'Trusted Traveler' joke program. That's currently. I'm reasonably sure that by the end of this calendar year congress will have been led to believe that they are exempt from NSA spying, and a certain 1% actually will be exempt from NSA spying.

Tiered privacy, coming soon to a democracy near you. "How much Privacy can you afford™"


#6

I hope this means congress will work toward better privacy protection for all of us instead of better privacy protection for members of congress.


#7

Were they sure to place the "beware of the leopard" sign on the disused lavatory? (makes all the difference)


#8

I'm so tired of this blatant prevarication. If any of us tried these kinds of responses in court, we’d be charged with contempt and jailed so quickly we wouldn't have time to pick up a glass of water.

Will anyone in Congress have the cojones to call them out on this crap?


#9

yea just like they are working towards equal opportunities and fair pay for everyone...oh right yeah, no they won't.


#10

I am completely fine by this. The only way to effect change is to have those in power feel as threatened as we are. I'm sure a lot of these people remember the kind of stuff hoover pulled.

Of course having said that I'm sure all that will be done is congress getting an exemption from spying.


#11

NSA is fully committed to transparency with Congress.

Except they have already established a pattern of lying to Congress, and this statement is false if it's false. What's the opposite of a paradox? A tautology? One of those.

And didn't we recently have a President who was impeached for lying to Congress? Is it therefore safe to assume that the Director of the NSA is more powerful than the President?


#12

That's like a headline. No.


#13

Speaking of cojones, the quoted NSA statement accidentally left out the loud "GLONNNNG!" at the end.
The sound of ginormous brass ones clanging as they walked away.

So, if I should call my Congress critter to complain of the NSA's violation of my rights, the NSA will collect the metadata (and, quite possibly the actual content) of my communication. Nice one, NSA! You've create a freakin' informational tesseract!


#14

I'm disappointed at the eye-in-the-pyramid image used to illustrate this post. I mean, you're saying that we're being constantly watched by a shadowy, unseen conspiracy that's malevolently pulling the strings of government and callously crushing innocent people's lives in order to maintain their dominion.

So, Cory, why tar the poor Illuminati by dragging them into a post about such an evil organization?


#15

So I would go a step further and require cell companies to publish the metadata of elected officials.

https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/require-cell-companies-publicly-provide-metadata-regarding-telephone-calls-all-nationally-elected/w9ZXTPH7


#16

And those who are suspicious will be shown their browsing, phone and email history for the past 10 years and reminded about the possibility of future 'leaks'.


#17

Nah, then they'll know for sure what the stakes are. I imagine they'll be shown nothing and reminded about the possibility of future leaks.


#18

Well, there is always the possibility of a couple of Critters being sacrificed 'pour encourager les autres'. A couple of Senators going down in flames of ignominy would be more than enough to cow most of them.

Of course, the NSA can also just make shit up. If they can tap everything they can likely do some amazing photoshopping, plant some incriminating things in our email history and any amount of other shittery.


#19

The last several times they've been asked questions like that in Congress they've turned out to have been lying. If anyone believes them this time, I've got a rich nigerian uncle who needs to get his money out of the country I'd like to introduce him to.


#20

It worked for a few years for videotape rental records, after Judge Bork turned out not to have rented anything as embarassing as his judicial decisions.

As far as "are NSA officials lying to Congress" goes, it depends on what your definition of "is" is.