Holy carp, I had no idea. Thanks for that! (Yes I have seen the original.)
You know, I’m a little disappointed by how little everyone involved in this seems to know about the Caribbean pirates and their treatment of white christian women.
Caribbean buccaneers weren’t typically farmboys from Clonagh who decided one day to drop the plough and take up a glamorous life of piratin’. Nor did they appear from thin air, fully formed.
Many were simple men who left the countryside for the big city to make their fortune, who were then seized by quasi-official “press gangs” of duplicitous thugs and forced into slavery aboard British privateers or warships, under horrifyingly harsh conditions. Hundreds of thousands of such impressments occurred, and pressed men took every chance to desert that was presented to them - sometimes, that chance was specifically piracy. Such men were not predisposed by their circumstances to hold white Christian women in exceptionally low regard - quite the opposite.
And while certainly many pirates were brutal, rapacious men, and the treatment of both male and female non-Europeans by pirates in the age of sail was indefensibly appalling, the treatment of captured* white Christian women compares fairly well with the treatment of such women in so-called “civilized” cultures of the time. A married woman in London or Paris could be terribly mistreated by her husband with considerably less recourse than a woman in New Providence or Tortuga. And while there were no women captaining British warships, privateers, pirate hunters or merchantment, there were certainly women pirates, including female pirate captains, who held power and position in their own right.
So strangely enough, the imagery of some women being cheerful and others weeping at a pirate bride auction is probably more accurate than any politically correct version ever could be, while the image of pirates as jolly, happy-go-lucky heroes is a pretty insane mischaracterization. It’s just that bride auctioning was no doubt quite rare, if it ever happened.
From Black Bart’s Articles:
No boy or woman to be allowed amongst them. If any man shall be found seducing any of the latter sex and carrying her to sea in disguise he shall suffer death.
From the Articles of the Revenge, 1724:
If at any time we meet with a Prudent Woman, that man that offers to meddle with her, without her Consent, shall suffer Present Death.
* because of the surety of conflict among the crew when a woman was aboard a pirate vessel, some captains simply executed or threw overboard any woman, instead of taking them captive. Blackbeard was said to strangle them personally. Permitting such captives to be raped was a sure way to breed mutiny; Morgan, for example, treated white Christian women captives with courtesy and respect, despite his frequently demonstrated callousness and cruelty towards men and all natives.