Oddly this is fine on my home lappy that has a 17" screen. But the external monitor at work, lots of white space on the right.
What do I look like, Pakistani Denzel?
No a Pakistani Dalek!
2 Likes
I know, I saw.
FYI, my notifications seem to be malfunctioning.
I didnāt even know that you had replied to my comment until now.
They can be lateā¦ Also I tend to get a reply notification then a quote notification later. shrug
personally I think @codinghorror and his crew have made a damn nice BBS even with the minor annoyances.
3 Likes
I donāt recall saying that they havenāt.
Of all the sites Iāve ever frequented, the BBS is one of the few thatās got a really good rapport with its membership regarding taking their input into account.
7 Likes
Bit of a scrum over the timeline though. It seems more rugby style than chickens and pigs, but probably healthy none the less.
4 Likes
Funnily enough I cough wrote a blog entry that covers this exact situation https://blog.codinghorror.com/chickens-pigs-and-really-inappropriate-terminology/
1 Like
my biggest issue is not the slider but the huge blue reply blob near my field of vision
2 Likes
But seriously, as I read the above feedback, the moving part is the bigger distraction, and that is absolutely the position / scrollbar which I do think looks fine ā arguably better ā in a more sedate monochrome.
I agree the position bar didnāt need to be so blue and attention grabbing. That is deployed now!
The right gutter topic reply button is consistent with the bottom-most topic reply button. Note that it also disappears when you scroll all the way down, since it would be duplicating that button.
5 Likes
I like the more muted blue. Iām still not sure what Iām gaining by having an extra way to scroll, and the dates over there. Maybe some others find it useful.
3 Likes
So there has definitely been something about the scrollbar which has been putting me off it since it was released, but I havenāt been able to identify what it was until just now while I was reading @renkeās comment about it moving.
When you click the scrollbar to scroll to a different post it moves and the post # listed next to it changes, but the posts donāt actually moveā¦ and this may sound weird, but I think it may actually be giving me a little bit of motion sickness 
. This is only compounded by the fact that when you scroll from say post #1 to post #51 in a topic with the new scrollbar it has to reload the topic page, however I realize that a scrollbar on the bbs has to work this way based on how the BBS loads posts. All of this goes back to what @renke is saying though, when I scroll with the already existing scrollbar in my browser I see the posts move, and I donāt have to reload the topic, but having the UI on the BBS for moving through a topic be a scrollbar that without visually moving postsā¦ Iām just not sure about it yet.
EDIT: Iām starting to wonder if this is literally about feedback, and I donāt mean as in us giving you feedback @codinghorror but as in haptic feedback. The scrollbar doesnāt create any feedback, other than the numbers next to it changing and it moving up and down its line, I have nothing to gauge on how far I have moved through the āspaceā of the web page, using the scrollbar eliminates the illusion of a topic existing as a physical space or room inside the BBS and it is very disorienting. In comparison a standard web browser scrollbar causes the entire page to move.
4 Likes
No sickness here. I agree about the scrolling and not having the posts move.
ETA: Retracting the statement about post numbers. I was off about that.The posts need to scroll if you use the timeline bar for it to make sense.
2 Likes
Hm, could the scrollbar be replaced with something more like the post/topic tracker you get when you are replying to someone in a thread, maybe you could have it also display the most recent post and first post dates on either side of it, you could even make the blue highlighted part of it be draggable if you really wanted to and still show the post date of the post you are currently looking atā¦ like a sideways scroll bar? I just feel like that would be less disorienting, but then again if the posts still arenāt moving when you are dragging or adjusting even a sideways scroll bar it still might feel off, thoughts?
EDIT: Oh, you already get something like this when you use the ā#ā keyboard shortcut.
1 Like
Regarding the āReplyā button at the bottom of the timeline, I agree with the earlier comment that it really grabs attention visually, but I think it might be more problematic than that.
If reading is more important than writing, why add a shortcut to commenting on a topic without at least scrolling through the existing ones? Having a āreply to threadā button floating on the side will just encourage people to reply without reading preceding comments, which is already enough of an issue as it is.
3 Likes
Agreed, but
-
Thereās no real way of stopping people from replying early if they are hell bent on doing it. At least the editor does not prevent them from reading as they reply, here. Or even navigating to a completely different topic altogether while editing. It all works.
-
If they are gonna reply early, theyāll jam āreplyā on the first post they see that sets them off anyhow ā¦ which is effectively the same thing. You know, people are Frequently Wrong On The Internet.
Longer term I think things like showing, for new users, how many posts they read in the topic next to their username ā will have a more significant deterrent effect than hiding the reply button from them.
(and we werenāt really even doing that, because every post has a reply button, yes?)
3 Likes
Honestly Iām speaking from what we have now. Iām not keeping a local copy of the git repo, if there is one. 
Speaking specificly to the reply per post, yes thatās always existed and should probably stay. It requires you to reply to an individual though. Thatās different than replying to a topic. People respond.
1 Like
Right but in terms of
scroll until I am pissed off enough to prove someone is Wrong on The Internet, then slam the Reply button on their post
there is 0.0% difference.
I suppose. Has it statistically worked out that way? (Youāre in the position to have data on something like this.)
If you stop on me specifically, I guarantee youāll get a different response than if you just tack it on the end of a thread.
