Freeze Peach 🍑 (USA)

Family wisdom here, having grown up with 2 brothers, is as follows: “One boy, one brain, 2 boys, half a brain, 3 boys, no brain.” Hypothetically, after that it enters negative numbers and begins to suck wisdom from the surroundings. Or, you could just go with the time-tested Tommy Lee Jones quote

image

9 Likes

I love MIB and quote that line fairly often. But I don’t take it to mean that individual people suddenly stop being smart in a crowd; rather that the pressure to conform and the practical exigencies created by the dumb panicky dangerous people limit the options of those who don’t, for example, stockpile toilet paper or fill trash bags with gasoline.

8 Likes

True, but I would think that crowd dynamics (as in: situational stupidity and/or bigotry resulting in violence) and group dynamics (as in societally accepted/promoted stupidity and/or bigotry resulting in irrational behaviour up to violence) are slightly different sides of the same medal.

3 Likes

Sorry there is no such unicorn called “True Freedom of Speech”. Freedom of speach is not actually free. The constitution grants it to every citizen, but its paid for by the military. Sometimes the price is high, where the service member gives his life to defend your rights.

Now having said that, freedom of speech comes with consequences at all times. One can not yell fire in a theater, the consequence is you get arrested. One can not cuss out ones boss, the consequences is you get fired.

For every action there is a reaction. For example, lets say you are attempting to burn the American flag in public. You have that right, and its covered under freedom of speech. I as a veteran take offense, i scream and cuss you out, and then clock you to rescue the flag. Your consequences is getting clocked, mine could be to get arrested for assault and theft of private property. We both exercised our freedoms, but neither escapes the consequences.

Another example would be to talk openly about killing an elected official, that would get you arrested.

1 Like

So, in short, there is no such thing as “consequence-free” speech, just as there are consequences for every other action.

Not sure how clocking someone constitutes speech, whether free or not, but I would avoid it.

7 Likes

Freedom isn’t free; it is known. But to follow from that there’s no such thing as freedom is a fallacy which conflates freedom having a cost with freedom being denied. The word free does not refer solely to price. And the argument that freedom is a myth by comparing it to a mythical creature because it has a price is the kind of absolutist nonsense no one with any sense should seriously countenance.

Also, welcome to Boing Boing. While I don’t agree with everything in your comment, I hope you stick around to engage with the community in a spirit of baseline mutual respect for your interlocutors.

13 Likes

ha ha no

15 Likes

Since when has the US military last protected or fought for an American’s right to free speech? Afghanistan? Iraq? Iran? Syria? Vietnam? Korea?

11 Likes

You seem to be conflating a few things. First Amendment guarantees of freedom of speech mean that you cannot be prosecuted by the government for most speech. It does not (as you rightly point out) equate to consequence free speech, nor to any requirement for platforming. And most importantly, IMHO, it does not mean anyone can be made to pay any attention. There is a common position on the snowflake right that there is a right to have your speech broadcast and taken seriously. No such right exists. Only that you cannot be arrested for it.

15 Likes

I don’t know what world you live in that physical assault on another person ( a crime) is considered “freedom,” but I never want to go there.

16 Likes

No. Physical violence != speech. The consequence for assault is the slammer.

Since you’re new here you might want to review the BBS rules. Here’s the relevant bit, bolded for your benefit:

  • Be cool. Don’t post or encourage insulting, bullying, victim-blaming, racist, sexist, violent, homophobic or transphobic remarks.
13 Likes

I assume you have the same violent reaction when you see someone wearing clothing with either the U.S. flag or some bastardization of it?

13 Likes

So with your reasoning, you’re willing accept veterans “clocking” police who fly blue lives matter flags? Or wearing symbols of flags on their clothes? Because both of these things are considered disrespectful to many veterans.

Also, veterans are not of one mind when it comes to defending the flag. My WWII veteran father would say that his service was to protect the right of Americans to burn the flag as a form of protest. If you have a problem with flag burning, you should have an equal problem with blue live matter flags or those tattered flags on cars.

Also, welcome to BBS!

12 Likes

Indeed. Those to whom symbols mean more than the ideals, however imperfectly observed, they represent, have lost the plot.

8 Likes

If your reaction to seeing a burning flag is to scream obscenities and punch people, you should probably talk to a therapist at the VA.

6 Likes

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.

Not as recently as organized labor has fought and died for free speech. Fly that flag on Labor Day and see how “patriots” respond.

8 Likes