In contrast, LeVar Burton is a real mensch. I knew people who worked on Reading Rainbow in the early 90’s. Burton was always nice and patient with even the lowliest production assistants. Very professional.
I found a video essay on disabilities in Star Trek and it seems that the depiction of Pike’s only got worse in the new stuff trying to veer back from the reboot movies. The part on Pike starts after 25 minutes in, but the video begins with Geordi La Forge. Melora’s also covered, but there was so much else bad with her episode.
This, I do not. At least to me, my desire to not be disabled has absolutely nothing to do with “other people’s expectations”, and I find it infuriatingly patronizing when people suggest that. (not that I’m saying that’s what you’re doing btw)
So actually, he’s not disabled at all. That’s not how it works IRL.
Now I don’t mind the trope of giving a disabled person a superpower to compensate. I really like Toph, from Avatar: the Last Airbender. What I like about her character is that she developed a separate ability on her own to compensate for her blindness, and in some ways it actually enhances her perception. Notably though, there’s no reason others wouldn’t be able to develop similar abilities (and indeed do so) other than that Toph has to rely on her earthbending more. Also, it doesn’t compensate fully: she still can’t read, see flying things, or really knows what people look like. And she makes jokes about that that make others uncomfortable.
IIRC there was only one episode where it got really silly, where Picard sent LaForge down to an observation deck and they implied his little VISOR was more sensitive than the entire sensorium of the whole starship
I guess the writers realized that was a mistake because I don’t think they ever did it again