That’s just our dear editor @beschizza saying that malarky in a fit of snarkiness, I thought. It wasn’t in the actual quotes, just Rob being Rob. A bit of woo bashing, which kinda balances out @frauenfelder 's enthusiasm for woo, I guess.
No, it’s in the article. I assume Rob deliberately quoted the stupidest thing I’ve seen today since somebody replied to a comment I made on Reddit with the phrase “cultural Marxism” in order to highlight the so stupid it hurts nature of the woo.
Kenji busted the ever-loving fuck out of this myth years ago. Shipping water cross-country to improve pizza is foolhardy at best and environmentally catastrophic at worst. Is Good Pizza Really All About the Water? | The Food Lab
I didn’t write this post, alas. My name ended up on it on BBS because I fatfingered the publish button editing it. But I absolutely stand by the deadpan recitation of marketing claims, just to see.
That’s just not true by any measure. NY style pizza dough typically has a hydration of 60-65%, meaning the amount of water used, by weight, is 60-65% of the weight of the flour used. So for 500g of flour, you’d have about 300g of water. And of course, some of that evaporates in the baking process. Some recipes of ciabatta bread use 100% hydration, but that kind of dough is really difficult to work with.