“Then I saw a great white throne and the octopus who was seated on it. The earth and the heavens fled from his tentacles, and there was no place for them. And I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne, and browsers were opened. A webpage was opened, which was Reddit. The dead were judged according to their karma. The sea gave up the dead that were in it, and death and Hades gave up the dead that were in them, and each person was judged according to their karma. Then death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. The lake of fire is the second death. Anyone whose username was not found on Reddit was thrown into the lake of fire.”
Well, you’ve got to feel a little sorry for the guy. You go to get your PhD with one of the world’s greatest astrophysicists, the guy who came up with the (sound) idea that chemical elements are created in stars. That week the guy is obsessed with a fun-but-ridiculous theory about life in the universe, so that’s what you end up doing. It would be like a chemistry grad student becoming Linus Pauling’s student just when he decided to devote the rest of his life to the benefits of vitamin C.
Ed Yong’s piece for the Atlantic is all gosh-wow and the argument is all “surely not a coincidence!”
P.Z. Myers is much more “Yeah, whatever, no big deal”.
You read of cephalopods editing their RNA, and think “Yay! They are genetic hackers, modifying their own source-code!” But it’s not obvious to me how this benefits them. Instead of DNA → mRNA → protein, the ADAR enzymes just mean that evolution in squiddlies works through one more layer of indirection: DNA → mRNA → modified mRNA → protein. The end result is the same… a mutation in the DNA ultimately results in a change in protein expression.
Intelligent Design is a far better answer. Especially since there NO sign of life elsewhere at this point. much less octopi life. And BTW it’s being proven that NONE of the evolution proposed for life has enough time. Not to mention that’s there’s still NO CLUE as to how life started in the 1st place… Outside of Special Creation. But hey that ol’ somedaymaybe science will work it all out i guess. But right NOW the science says there’s NOT enough time for evolution for even 3 small DNA changes to stick.
There’s a much more obvious explanation, but at the risk of upsetting those who have turned a failed 19th century idea into a full-blown religion, I’ll keep it to myself.
We all know what it is, though, and the more we learn, the stronger the evidence for it grows.