Should rock stacking be banned?


#1

#2

Scolders blame social media, but how long before vids of knocking over rock stacks becomes a thing. The invisible foot, innit? Balance restored to the galaxy.


#3

Any reaction from The Royal Society for Putting Things On Top Of Other Things yet?


#4

It’s either bad journalism or a bad argument, but having read through the article, I cannot identify any evidence for harm caused by this trend. And before we talk about banning something, it should at least be able to clear that low bar.


#5

I’m pretty sure it’s bad journalism. They are trying to report on an assertion that leaving behind evidence of humans visiting beaches, even if completely and easily reversible, is bad behaviour. BBC has a habit of angling to appear non-partisan by standing so far back that they lose the ability to apply sufficient critical reasoning needed make a meaningfully detailed report of things.

Common-or-garden British politeness to the point of uselessness and beyond. I yell at them all the time.


#6

Up next: A panicky article on how leaving footprints is bad for the environment, and we shouldn’t go to the beach anymore.


#7


#8

the problem with quotes


#9

Oh well

Favorite Lincoln quote


#10

I saw rangers knocking a bunch of cairns down in the Zion Narrows a couple weeks ago, I’m guessing there’s a pretty big consensus on the harm.


#11

I mostly find rock stacking presumptuous and annoying.

I came out to nature to find nature, not somebody showing off creating man made structures out of rocks.


#12

I would be totally down with rock stacking if there were two widely-observed rules:

  1. One rock per person.
  2. The stack should be as improbable as possible.

#13

I think the location is a key issue. It would be horrible to stack rocks on well used trails, or near important landmarks. But I have no problem with my kids doing it out in the actual wilderness. Which they do quite often.

Why must everything be either forbidden or compulsory? Could we not discourage rock stacking where it is likely to interfere with other’s outdoor experience?


#14

For me, rock stacking breaks the “leave no trace” philosophy of hiking and camping that I prefer. Do that shit at home.

It’s not a huge deal. But to me it is still a deal.


#15

#17

Not much benefit, beyond what you can get with a Jenga set.

It is outlawed in several parts of my state, partly because it disturbs important geological and anthropological evidence, partly because it is disruptive to coastal habitats, and partly because – depending on where it takes place – it can be blatant religious desecration.


#18

Well clearly, if you saw a thing, it must be a pretty big consensus. Why doesn’t Washington take on this menace? Simple cowardice, or are they in the pocket of Big Cairn?

Wait a minute… weren’t people advocating the death penalty last year for knocking down rock piles?


#19

Please control…
your Jesus…


#20

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.