Prof. Jodi Dean writes:
I am moved and grateful by the outpouring of solidarity I’ve received since I was suspended from teaching. Among the letters sent in my behalf is the one from Dana Naomi Mills, a peace activist in Tel Aviv. She’s given me permission to post it.
Dear President Gearan,
I hope this finds you well, in these turbulent times, and Happy Passover, if you, like me, are marking this holiday.
I worked as an academic for 20 years, holding positions in institutions including Tel Aviv University, University of Oxford (from which I also obtained a DPhil), NYU, Bard College and University of Amsterdam. I came across Prof. Dean’s work, and then met her in person. Both encounters have been transformative for me.
I was shocked and saddened to hear that Hobart and William Smith Colleges have relieved Prof. Dean of her teaching responsibilities due to her writing on the Israeli attacks on Gaza while claiming that her views might make students feel ‘unsafe’. This is a dangerous, volatile and undemocratic decision that has grave consequences for academic freedom and freedom of speech generally. I implore you to revoke this decision.
Like all Israelis, I was shocked deeply by the October 7 attacks. I have family lives in the South of Israel and I have many friends and comrades who were directly affected. Like many Israelis I also know some of the families of those taken hostage to Gaza. I know these attacks were shocking to Jews worldwide. These attacks are not without context; Israel’s occupation of Palestine, including a 17 year long siege on Gaza, cannot be erased when discussing these matters, including safety of Jews in Israel- Palestine and abroad. The case discussed in the ICJ regarding the crime of genocide (South Africa vs. Israel) is a watershed moment internationally.
Silencing critique of Israel will not make Israelis safer, nor will it make Jews in the diaspora safer. We, Israeli defenders of human rights, are shocked by the actions of our government, and know well that they won’t end without international pressure. Allowing this ruthless military assault to go unchecked is not only horrendous for Palestinian safety; it damages us Jews and Israelis, too. No one is free until everyone is free.
…
Shutting down debate on real- world politics by expelling academics is a dangerous precedent. Weaponizing questions of safety (and by extension, antisemitism-- Jewish safety) while silencing critique of Israel is dangerous in its own right and makes Jews around the world unsafe.
I am writing this to you as I am willing to speak out publicly on behalf of Prof. Dean, to connect to any student who might wish to speak with me; I would be very happy to have a correspondence or conversation on zoom about freedom of speech and Israel/ Palestine.
In 2020 I published a biography of Rosa Luxemburg, an activist and thinker both Prof. Dean and myself turn towards for inspiration. Prof. Dean wrote warmly and generously of the book; an endorsement that meant a lot to me. Luxemburg is famous for having written: ‘freedom is always and exclusively the freedom for the one who thinks differently’. I am asking you to consider this statement in the context of our times, revoke the decision considering Prof. Dean’s teaching responsibilities and return her immediately to your classrooms, especially this Passover, the Holiday of Freedom.
Please feel free to be in touch, connect me to anyone who has relevant queries, or pass on my contact to anyone who wishes to have an open conversation with an Israeli who is saddened and horrified by how her country’s actions are used to silence important voices and shut down debates.
Sincerely yours,
Dr. Dana Mills
Tel Aviv