Woman given maximum fine for walking into Australian airport with a rose

The context suggests that the ‘resisting arrest’ school of making things up probably isn’t at play.

That one’s natural environment seems to be post-hoc justification of unreasonable escalation on the cops’ part: if they flip out and decide to pick someone to turn into a police matter they have a strong incentive to find something that justifies doing so.

In the case of customs officers, unlike police officers, every customs declaration is a customs matter by default(albeit normally a super boring one); so casting around for some justification wouldn’t really be a factor unless they unreasonably escalate(and, if they decide to rip someone’s luggage to shreds or haul them off to one of the side rooms for hours of aggressive questioning I assume that they do have a strong interest in returning with a story of guilt, or at least plausible suspicion; for the same reasons as the cops in the ‘resisting arrest’ scenario); and pointing out that someone’s hand luggage directly contradicts their declaration isn’t really an escalation.

The customs case seems a lot more closely analogous to that of cops doing traffic enforcement; where it’s less about needing to fabricate crimes and more about the amount of discretion available to someone who can decide to let it slide, confiscate but agree that you clearly just made a good-faith error in the paperwork, or work from the assumption that you are a trade compliance expert steeped in deceit and count all discrepancies as malicious.

1 Like

Huh. I don’t think toilet cleaner I buy here in California has a scent, but I imagine if I grew up with toilets smelling like roses, I’d have a bad association too.

The thorns though… I kind of figured that would fit right in with Australia?

3 Likes

Feh. Years ago I was returning from a trip to the UK, on the flight they gave me a little box of corn flaks and for whatever reason I decided not to eat it & bring it home. Coming off the flight I declared it. The customs agent gave me this huge eye roll thing and told me I shouldn’t have bothered.

I was pretty sure at the time it was better to declare it then not, and now I’m still sure :wink:

2 Likes

We take biosecurity VERY seriously here in Australia, BECAUSE of the mistakes of the past.

As to why “What a bunch of hypocrites for trying to do better in the so called “modern” day” here is one current example of the problems a laps in biosecurity can cause::

6 Likes
2 Likes

There’s at least two good answers to this from Ursula Vernon (as T. Kingfisher):

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.