Nope, men and women aren’t equally sexualized in comics

Are you kidding? This thread jumped the shark sometime yesterday afternoon. At this point, we may as well let it go for another 15 comments to get an even 500.

4 Likes

Oh, no, we MUST go comfort him, RIGHT NOW… I’m ready to give him lots of hugs.

Any idea why? the costume?

NOOOOO!!! This thread is my only friend!!!

7 Likes

Did you even read the article… because it looks like you just read the headline and flipped out.

2 Likes

3 Likes

You rang?

3 Likes

Whilst I disagree with TheRizz’s simplistic and ill-defined analysis I don’t think it is any more simplistic than female Thor = more sales.

The gender change of Thor is certainly not the only factor that could be at play. The publicity generated by it (referred to by TheRizz as “car wreck effect” could easily be a factor as could a change in the market for comics, increased awareness of the Marvel brand along with dozens of other environmental and product-specific marketing variables. There’s just not enough data available currently to support any given theory regarding the increased sales and pointing to one factor and say it is (or isn’t) responsible is, at best, misguided.

1 Like

There are others that are enjoying the thread.

Instead of asking that the thread be closed, you could… just watch? Go to another thread? Play a game? Marvel at the moisture that falls from the skies outside these very walls?

Wait. I thought we were Cultural Marxists.

We’re not?

9 Likes

I want to go to a Marxist disco!!!

Also…

6 Likes

Yeah, I know - it’s a stretch… I thought that would signpost the joke effectively.

1 Like

This has GOT to be from the 80s.

(I grew up near Sheffield, in the 80’s; back when getting into a disco might be expected to cost 50p)

1 Like

What’s sad is that someone thinks it’s true… ignoring the variety of political views around here. We’re a heterogeneous bunch up in these parts of cyberspace!

Come on people… we’re two… well, now 1 away from 500. Don’t disappoint me, please!

The best thing about this is that they seem to think they’re trolling us.

What’s really funny is that some people self-identify with it so strongly that they can’t accept a joke about it from one of their Guardian-reading own…

I found it doing an image search for “bad marxists”.

Now, trying to research the image itself I find it’s an artwork by one Scott King:

oooooh! He was an arti director for iD magazine! :wink:

3 Likes

and a partridge in a pear tree?

2 Likes

Incidentally, on the original topic I’ve thought about what we’ve discussed and I think you’re right. In the medium of comic books, female characters are more sexualized, and certainly more purely sexualized than the male. I don’t think that comics are exceptional in this, but it’s as true of them as in other media.

That’s not to claim that male characters aren’t sexualized. More importantly, because I think this is where the controversy lies, it would also be (more) unreasonable to claim that male characters aren’t objectified. I think the confusion arises because discussions of objectification generally refer to sexual objectification. In comic books, I think both male and female characters are objectified, and the male objectification often or usually includes a sexual component, whereas the female objectification is chiefly (but rarely only) sexual. But the sense of alienation, and the impact upon self esteem for those who ‘don’t pass’ and are sensitive about it, is very similar.

This mix of marginalised males intersecting with marginalised others and ideological progressives (some of whom are really rather conservative in their approach) then becomes a complete shitfight, firstly because of misunderstanding and then swiftly because of malice.

I’m not excusing those marginalised males who as a result of the above choose to express themselves like complete arseholes. I’m more interested in understanding and avoiding the proliferation of this kind of mobbing. To be flippant, every neckbeard who doesn’t buy a gun and vote Teaparty, or who doesn’t start slutshaming or gamergating is a win. I do think that we need to recognise our own arseholes as well, though, which may involve the use of mirrors however literally or figuratively you choose to take it.

1 Like
2 Likes