NYT first article about Hitler (1922): his "anti-Semitism not so genuine or violent as it sounded"

Thanks, I like that guy, especially his movie recs, but I think he’s wrong here. Just because Trump and our times differ in some ways from those of other fascists in other times doesn’t mean that pointing out resemblances isn’t an instructive way of clarifying how a new leader and his followers scarily resemble fascism.

Does something have to precisely resemble something else for a comparison of the two to be useful? Not in most cases, but when it comes to Hitler and/or other fascists, suddenly a lot of people think it does.

ETA: as @Purplecat says in another of the 534 bbs threads on Trump,

When even The Daily Mail thinks someone is a bit of an extreme right winger, then you know you’ve got problems.

So, um, just how far to the right does Drumpf and his movement have to be before the comparison to Hitler and/or other fascists becomes fair enough for you?

4 Likes