PBS: why do some people hate cilantro?

Sorry cilantro is such a miserable trial for you, Mr. F.

Could be worse.

No, really.

The brown marmorated shield bug (AKA “stink bug”) produces similar aldehydes when startled or just hot and annoyed. Its trans-2-decenal is the same as in cilantro but the shorter chain trans-2-OCTenal is even stinkier.

On the plus side, these compounds are anti-bacterial as well as anti-personnel since nothing can stand to be near the stench.

Ammonia solution cut with rubbing alcohol seems to remove the indelicate aroma adequately.

2 Likes

The molecular gastronomy wonks did flavor analyses on fresh cilantro to see what else lined up with its chemical matrix. With the standout compound linalool, usually found in cinnamon, lavender, and fruit peel, cilantro overlapped with strawberries.

That said, strawberries lightly garnished with bruised cilantro leaf go well with an off-dry viognier wine, also noted for its overlap with strawberry flavors.

And a dill pickle in your Caesar. (pickled cuke, that is).

2 Likes

Yeah, kinda like those homosexuals who chose to be sexually interested in the same gender.

2 Likes

Never heard of it. Looked it up. Now I want one.

1 Like

Wow, I admit that I was trolling a little bit but I’m proud to have found someone who can make such monumental and tasteless false-equivalencies.

Why don’t you tell us: who exactly is the Matthew Shepard of people who find cilantro disagreeable?

I don’t know and I don’t care. However, I have little patience with people who, even if “just trolling”, tell other people that the traits they are born with are somehow “wrong” and that they are an inferior form of humans.

Of course it’s a sliding scale: Homosexuals are actively prosecuted and have to fear for their lives in many countries while Cilantro-“Haters” just get told that their taste buds don’t matter. But it’s the same assholery as not taking someone’s allergies serious.

3 Likes

For something to be on the Schedule I list (per the OP), doesn’t it have to first, be something fun?

It doesn’t specifically taste like soap to me, per se (someone above had mentioned bleach, and that comes closer), but it nullifies / overwhelms the taste of the food it’s on… which is the flavor I wanted in the first place.

1 Like

I have found that the answer to this question is yes, even if it isn’t strictly true. Your body reacts badly to it regardless. My digestive systems reaction to onions isn’t technically an allergy, but it is very unpleasant for the week after eating some.

2 Likes

Oh, man. You’re right. You disliking the taste of cilantro is exactly the same as someone dying because they ate a peanut. I’m definitely the insensitive one here.

Sounds like a really hard life. My deepest sympathies. #alltastebudsmatter

There are many, if not most that understand the hatred of cilantro, onions, blue cheese, and olives (curse you, devil fruit!). I prefer to experience something like food before I judge how I react to it. I use food as an example because I already know how I’d react to base jumping and Nascar. The list goes on.

I won’t disparage those that like or dislike things–except for olives and Chicago style pizza, cause that’s a lasagna, and it is a decade long Kaufman style running joke–and in principle I 100% agree not to denigrate people for their preferences.

Except olives (Satan’s handywork!), And Chicago style pizza (it’s delicious! It isn’t pizza!)

4 Likes

its not the same thing though they come from the same plant.

Coriander and Cilantro do not have the same flavor profile and because they are very different from a plant matter standpoint, they have to also be used and treated differently.

I cannot toast Cilantro…but coriander seeds should absolutely be toasted and cracked/ground for full flavor.

2 Likes

Post removed

1 Like

Essential flavouring for proper sausages also.

I get thinking that cilantro tastes like soap. It kind of does. But it tastes like delicious soap.

2 Likes

I took it as dry humor.

But olive hate? How can anyone not take that seriously? You can’t make a muffuletta without olive salad!

central-grocery-olive-spread-img_7213

9 Likes

Soapy cilantro taste can be overcome through perseverance. I promise.

1 Like

Cilantro is the people’s herb. You’re just a shill for Big Sage.

7 Likes

I get a little of the soap taste, but still enjoy cilantro. That said, there’s NO way that I’m going to go through the huge bunches that they sell in stores. 1/10th of a bunch, being very picky with the leaves, is enough cilantro to weaponize the food we make in a week.

3 Likes

@DukeTrout

You have to eat it every day and your body will change. Marriage to a Mexican will accomplish this in short order.

4 Likes