Russian city "bans yoga" because of "occult character"


#1

[Read the post]


#2

I’m beginning to doubt the image I was sold in the 70’s of evil chess playing mathematical geniuses toiling away at complex machinations aimed at bringing an end to the corrupt and decadent west. Turns out, they are more along the lines of Appalachian Evangelicals slappin’ bellies running from the devil.


#3

:smiley: :smiley: :smiley:


#4

If only we’d moved faster, here in the United States.


#5

How/why are “new religious cults and movements” any worse or less desirable than old ones?

And how does this jive with Yoga being about 3000 years old? How is that “new”, precisely? Newer than what?


How/why are "new religious cults and movements" any worse or less desirable than old ones?
#6

Well, the evangelicals do seem to have a hotline to comrade Putin…
Internet preacher: Because SCOTUS gay marriage ruling, Putin will destroy America for Jesus - Boing Boing


#7

They are right on the substance. Before it was turned into hip gymnastics in the West, Yoga was a serious branch of Hindu religion/philosophy/way of life. It was practiced with the intent to achieve liberation through introspective examination of one’s psychological states and perceptions - something totally incompatible with Christianity, as it is currently generally preached and understood. The physical exercise part of it, with which it is now primarily associated, is only a minor aspect of the whole thing.


#8

But what substance is that? It still makes no sense with regards to their claims of wanting to avoid “new religions”, considering that it’s older than theirs.

The ideas some westerners may entertain about Yoga in no way changes nor undermines its character generally.

How it may be associated would seem to depend upon whom we ask.


#9

What we call yoga, ancient folks called isometric exercise.


#10

Wait, the city is called “Putinland”? Are you sure this wasn’t a story from the Onion?


#11

I’m not saying I agree with them in banning it.

I suppose they are arguing it’s “new” to the ~traditionally Orthodox-Christian Russia, the same way Christianity was new to the Americas.


#12

At least parent’s efforts to ban yoga in public schools recently got thwarted:
California Appeals Court Rules Yoga Doesn’t Violate Religious Freedom - WSJ

A California appeals court ruled last week that a school district in Encinitas could incorporate yoga into physical education, rejecting a challenge by parents who said the millennia-old discipline violates religious-freedom provisions in California’s constitution, which are broader than those in the U.S. Constitution.

#13

There’s a pretty substantial difference between being ‘inextricably linked to religious practices’ and being ‘extricably linked to religious practices’.

It would be pointless to argue that ‘yoga’ wasn’t cribbed from specifically Hindu sources, since it was; but it would be fairly easy to argue that a fully dereligionized version is not that hard to deliver, and in practice is delivered much of the time.


#14

Traditionally, wasn’t the Sovi… erm excuse me… Russia, atheist?


#15

It used to be. However, now the historical pendulum is swinging to the other side, and the Church apparently became a considerable power in the rural areas, and catering to its whims seems to be a good career move. Plus the need to ideologically differ from the Decadent West, kind of like why the god thing was placed on the money by the US to cater to the whims of the religious and to differ from the Decadent Communists.

More of the same, just from the other side now.


#16

This topic was automatically closed after 5 days. New replies are no longer allowed.